Thursday, March 28, 2024
ADVT 
National

Drug Conviction Quashed Because Ottawa Officers Lied; Breached Woman's Rights

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 26 May, 2016 01:35 PM
    TORONTO — A woman found with marijuana in her car trunk has won an acquittal on appeal, in part because police violated her rights with an unnecessary high-risk takedown and then lied about what had happened.
     
    In a decision this week, Ontario's top court rejected prosecution arguments that the rights violations were minor or only happened after police had already found the drugs.
     
    "The admission of the marijuana would bring the administration of justice into disrepute," the Appeal Court said.
     
    "This is one of those cases in which the court's need to disassociate itself from the police's conduct is greater than society's interest in prosecuting (the accused)."
     
    The case arose in June 2010 when Ottawa police saw Eneida Pino, 43, leave a suspected grow-op and put a box in the trunk of her car. As she and another man were driving, two officers in an unmarked cruiser forced them to stop.
     
    One officer, Det. Jason Savory, was dressed in black, his face was covered with a balaclava. With his gun pointed at the occupants, Savory yelled at them to get out of the car. Pino was arrested and handcuffed before Savory and Const. Marco Dinardo searched the car and found the marijuana.
     
    At trial, Ontario court Judge David Paciocco concluded the officers had lied about whether Savory had drawn his gun and that the stop had been routine.
     
     
    In all, Paciocco found three violations of Pino's rights: that the arrest by way of a dangerous and unnecessary masked takedown at gunpoint was unreasonable, that the officers misinformed her about her right to counsel, and that police held her in a cell for more than five hours before allowing her to call a lawyer. Nevertheless, he refused to exclude the marijuana evidence and convicted Pino of possession for the purposes of trafficking.
     
    In quashing the conviction, the Ontario Court of Appeal agreed with Paciocco's findings, but not his conclusion to allow the drug evidence.
     
    That the violations of her right to counsel occurred only after discovery of the drugs did not automatically mean the evidence should be admissible given all the circumstances, the Appeal Court found.
     
    "This is a difficult issue (but) the court should consider the entire 'chain of events' between the accused and the police," the Appeal Court said.
     
    "The marijuana seized from the trunk of Ms. Pino's car and all three Charter breaches are part of the same transaction...Ms. Pino's arrest."
     
    The Appeal Court also rejected the prosecution argument and the judge's finding that the violations were relatively harmless, finding instead that the breaches were close to the "extreme end of seriousness."
     
    The fact that the officers had lied at trial was especially problematic, the Appeal Court found.
     
    "For the purpose of assessing the seriousness of the Charter breaches and the overall assessment of whether the marijuana should have been excluded from the evidence at trial, the officers' dishonest testimony should not be understated," the Appeal court ruled.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Kathleen Wynne Praises Notley In Edmonton Says Climate Plan Gives Social Licence

    Kathleen Wynne Praises Notley In Edmonton Says Climate Plan Gives Social Licence
    Wynne says Notley's blueprint to reduce Alberta's carbon footprint gives the province more social licence to pitch for more energy infrastructure such as pipelines.

    Kathleen Wynne Praises Notley In Edmonton Says Climate Plan Gives Social Licence

    Fewer Provincial Exams, More In-Class Assessment In B.C. Starting Next Year

    Fewer Provincial Exams, More In-Class Assessment In B.C. Starting Next Year
    Teachers will assess Grade 10 math, language arts and science in the classroom instead of through provincial exams.

    Fewer Provincial Exams, More In-Class Assessment In B.C. Starting Next Year

    Victoria Woman Charged With Fraud For Allegedly Posing As Wildfire Evacuee

    Victoria Woman Charged With Fraud For Allegedly Posing As Wildfire Evacuee
    Another person has been charged for allegedly posing as a Fort McMurray wildfire evacuees.

    Victoria Woman Charged With Fraud For Allegedly Posing As Wildfire Evacuee

    Musicians To Play Benefit Concert To Help People Affected By Fort McMurray Fire

    Musicians To Play Benefit Concert To Help People Affected By Fort McMurray Fire
    Some of the artists who are to play the June 29 Fire Aid benefit concert in Edmonton include Nickelback, Blue Rodeo, Corb Lund and Ian Tyson.

    Musicians To Play Benefit Concert To Help People Affected By Fort McMurray Fire

    Airbnb Says New Quebec Law Won't Be Only Model Regulating Home-Sharing Service

    Airbnb Says New Quebec Law Won't Be Only Model Regulating Home-Sharing Service
    "What works for one community may not work for another," Chip Conley, global head of strategy and hospitality, said in an interview.

    Airbnb Says New Quebec Law Won't Be Only Model Regulating Home-Sharing Service

    Pacific Fleet Commander Says No Room For Sexual Misconduct On Navy Ships

    Pacific Fleet Commander Says No Room For Sexual Misconduct On Navy Ships
    Rear Admiral Gilles Couturier said Wednesday in an interview with The Canadian Press he won't tolerate sexual misconduct offences in the Canadian Forces.

    Pacific Fleet Commander Says No Room For Sexual Misconduct On Navy Ships

    PrevNext