Thursday, March 28, 2024
ADVT 
National

Federal Parties Struggle To Stay On Top Of Offensive Facebook Comments

The Canadian Press, 25 Jan, 2015 02:24 PM
    OTTAWA — The recent terror attacks in Paris have unleashed a barrage of anti-Muslim and anti-immigrant comments on the Facebook pages of federal politicians and their parties in Canada — much of it plainly visible to the public.
     
    Managing racist, sexist, homophobic and harassing material is just one of the new challenges facing parties who want to have an active social media presence, grounded in the concept of free speech and open dialogue.
     
    A Jan. 7 post on Stephen Harper's Facebook account, in which the prime minister said he was "horrified by the barbaric attacks in France," received approximately 575 comments. Some six dozen — expressing support for blocking immigration from Islamic countries, closing Canada's borders or just criticizing Islam — were still on the page more than two weeks later.
     
    "Time to step down on all Islamic communities worldwide," wrote one visitor to the page.
     
    Said another: "All muslims should go home and never be let back here please mr harper make that happen they steal real peoples jobs that belong to us canadians."
     
    A Jan. 14 Conservative Party of Canada Facebook post entitled "Protecting Canadians from Barbaric Cultural Practices" — aimed at promoting the government's legislation barring forced or child marriages — elicited similar sentiments.
     
    One example: "Deport them all if you want to save Canada."  
     
    A handful of other comments were taken down after The Canadian Press asked the party last Tuesday about their Facebook policy.
     
    A few commenters expressed dismay with the vitriol against Muslims.
     
    "Wow ... so much hate, bigotry and fear mongering on this page! So sad to see that so many in Canada have been brainwashed to think like this," said one.
     
    Harper's Facebook presence is described on the site as a "family-friendly page," which notes that the administrators reserve the right to delete inappropriate submissions including hateful, malicious, uncivil or disrespectful content.
     
    Party spokesman Cory Hann explained that an online Facebook tool is used to screen out certain words, but the rest of the work falls to a party staff member who must scan the content manually.
     
    "With over 100,000 fans of our Facebook page, we do our best to keep up with the large volume of comments we get daily," Hann said.
     
    "Obviously it goes without saying we don't endorse every single comment, and work to remove inappropriate ones that the built-in filter does not pick up."
     
    Facebook pages for NDP Leader Tom Mulcair and Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau relating to the Paris attacks also included a sprinkling of comments critical of immigration from Muslim countries, all of them along similar lines.
     
    Both the NDP and the Liberals also have a policy against hate speech and racist comments on their Facebook pages.
     
    Privately, party insiders say keeping up with the sheer volume of comments can be difficult, given that staff are also taking care of a range of other tasks.
     
    Ian Capstick, managing partner of public relations firm MediaStyle, said major corporations will purchase a separate filtering program from Facebook's, plus hire staff or an outside firm to keep up with the comments.
     
    Capstick, a former Parliament Hill aide to NDP and Liberal politicians, says the real source of the problem for Canada's political parties is they still only see social media as a one-way conversation.
     
    "Canadian politicians are very good at using social media to broadcast, but they're very bad at using it to have actual conversations," said Capstick, whose firm does some social media management.
     
    "If there were more actual conversations going on, there would be more regular usage of those Facebook sites and Twitter accounts, and people would be cleaning them more regularly."
     
    The media industry has also grappled with the challenge of policing comments sections, and the racist, sexist or homophobic comments that can live there. Last year, the Chicago Sun-Times took down its comments sections in order to study the issue, while other sites have played down the sections.
     
    Paula Todd, digital media professor and author of "Extreme Mean: Trolls, Bullies and Predators Online," said some offensive speech should be left online so that it can be exposed and critiqued by others.
     
    But Todd, the chair of the digital issues committee at Canadian Journalists for Free Expression, said political parties have an obligation to ensure sites they're responsible for do not contain examples of hate speech.
     
    The Criminal Code's section on the "wilful incitement of hatred" describes a perpetrator as someone who "wilfully promotes hatred against any identifiable group." Such groups are defined by colour, race, religion, ethnic origin or sexual orientation.
     
    "We're discovering the effects of putting all this horrible stuff online," said Todd. 
     
    "One of the effects is that because it's 24 hours a day, because it flies around the world in seconds, and because it's permanent, these kinds of hate attacks can be more damaging than just the face to face."

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Four Arrested After Five People Shot In Toronto: Police

    Four Arrested After Five People Shot In Toronto: Police
    TORONTO — Four people have been arrested in a shooting in northwest Toronto that sent five people to hospital, one with life-threatening injuries, police said Thursday.

    Four Arrested After Five People Shot In Toronto: Police

    Moncton RCMP Search For Suspicious Man Reportedly Carrying Firearm

    Moncton RCMP Search For Suspicious Man Reportedly Carrying Firearm
    MONCTON, N.B. — RCMP officers are searching a neighbourhood in Moncton, N.B., after receiving a report today of a suspicious male walking down a street with what appeared to be a firearm.

    Moncton RCMP Search For Suspicious Man Reportedly Carrying Firearm

    Stephen Harper Government Braces For Grilling On Oil Price Plunge, Sputtering Economy

    Stephen Harper Government Braces For Grilling On Oil Price Plunge, Sputtering Economy
    OTTAWA — Prime Minister Stephen Harper is trying to set the tone for Monday's resumption of Parliament by vowing his government will focus on jobs and economic security.

    Stephen Harper Government Braces For Grilling On Oil Price Plunge, Sputtering Economy

    When Like Doesn't Mean Like: Experts Say There's Nuance To Facebook Behaviour

    When Like Doesn't Mean Like: Experts Say There's Nuance To Facebook Behaviour
    A Like shouldn't always be taken literally, say tech experts, who are closely watching the case of 13 Dalhousie University students suspended for their actions on Facebook.

    When Like Doesn't Mean Like: Experts Say There's Nuance To Facebook Behaviour

    No Winner For Saturday's $5 Million Lotto 649 Jackpot

    No Winner For Saturday's $5 Million Lotto 649 Jackpot
    TORONTO — No winning tickets were sold for Saturday night's $5 million Lotto 649 jackpot.

    No Winner For Saturday's $5 Million Lotto 649 Jackpot

    Quebec Immigration Minister Kathleen Weil Prepares For 'Ottawa-inspired' Reform

    Quebec Immigration Minister Kathleen Weil Prepares For 'Ottawa-inspired' Reform
    Quebec is preparing for a major reform of its immigration policy, with proposed changes partly inspired by Ottawa, says the province's immigration minister.

    Quebec Immigration Minister Kathleen Weil Prepares For 'Ottawa-inspired' Reform

    PrevNext