Thursday, March 28, 2024
ADVT 
National

Not criminally responsible defence not a 'get out of jail free card': expert

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 17 Dec, 2014 03:18 PM

    TORONTO — Critics may see it as an easy way out, but defence lawyers argue those seeking to be declared not criminally responsible for their crimes must overcome serious hurdles at trial and may end up spending more time in custody than if they had pleaded guilty.

    The system meant for those whose mental illness is so severe they can't tell right from wrong has come under renewed scrutiny as jurors in Toronto and Montreal weigh two high-profile murder cases that hinge on the oft-misunderstood defence.

    "The widespread perception is that this is a get-out-of-jail-free card that anybody can play and kind of make a mockery of the system. In fact, nothing could be further from the truth," said David Butt, a Toronto barrister who has argued for not-criminally-responsible verdicts on behalf of several clients.

    Unlike a standard defence, which only requires undermining the Crown's case to the point of reasonable doubt, lawyers pushing for a finding of not criminally responsible must prove their client meets a "very significant psychiatric threshold," Butt said.

    "The kinds of NCR defences that succeed are when people commit terrible acts under the honest and truly held but completely psychotic belief that the person they're killing is an alien who's invading the Earth and they're the only person who can stop this terrible scourge. So, completely disconnected from reality in a very florid and pronounced way," he said.

    "If you don't have that and you don't have a reputable forensic psychiatrist who will come to court and say that, you don't even have the beginnings of an NCR defence," he said.

    Lawyers must also overcome jurors' lack of psychiatric expertise and possible misgivings about the defence, particularly in cases involving horrific crimes or premeditation, Butt said.

    "What's really difficult to wrap one's head around is the fact that a person can engage in very thoughtful, deliberate, careful conduct in planning and carrying out a killing and still be in a completely altered reality," he said. "The lay perception is that if you're floridly mentally ill then you're incapable of any thoughtful action."

    A Supreme Court of Canada decision in 2000 found a "real danger" that juries could be "unduly skeptical" of what is often perceived as an easily fabricated defence.

    In Montreal, Luka Rocco Magnotta is charged with first-degree murder and four other charges in the slaying and dismemberment of Chinese engineering student Jun Lin in May 2012.

    Meanwhile, in Toronto, Christopher Husbands faces multiple charges, including two counts of first-degree murder, in a deadly shooting at Toronto's Eaton Centre in June of that year.

    Both have pleaded not guilty and are seeking to be found not criminally responsible by way of mental disorder.

    Several other prominent cases have recently fuelled debate over the defence and prompted the Conservative government to pass controversial legislative changes to tighten restrictions on some offenders found not criminally responsible.

    However, the number of not-criminally-responsible verdicts has dropped over time, according to a Statistics Canada study released this year that compiled data from all provinces and territories except Quebec, Yukon and the Northwest Territories.

    Such verdicts were delivered in 268 cases across Canada in 2011-12, the latest data available, compared with 280 the previous year, the data show. In 2005-06, the earliest year studied, there were 284.

    They represent a small fraction of more than 300,000 total criminal cases processed by Canadian courts each year. Homicides make up roughly one per cent of cases resulting in an NCR verdict, while major assault accounts for about 20 per cent, the study shows.

    Once someone is found not criminally responsible, they are managed by review boards — independent tribunals made up of at least five people, including at least one psychiatrist.

    Each year people in most NCR cases go before their province’s review board. It can order that the person remain detained in a hospital, with varying levels of privileges, it can release the person on a conditional discharge or order an absolute discharge.

    Absolute discharges are granted only when the board finds the person is not a "significant threat" to public safety.

    While that may seem more appealing than jail time — particularly for offences carrying an automatic life sentence — in many cases, people end up spending more time in a custodial setting than they would have under a guilty plea, said Anita Szigeti, a Toronto lawyer specializing in mental health law.

    "Detention in the NCR stream is always indefinite — there's no capping, there's no end to it, it's not comparable to what you would serve in jail so if your offence is a maximum sentence of 10 years, that doesn't mean that 10 years down the road you'll be released from psychiatric attention," she said.

    "So it's not a free ride, it's not a cake walk, it's not getting away with murder — none of the things the public often believes that it might be."

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Four Arrested After Five People Shot In Toronto: Police

    Four Arrested After Five People Shot In Toronto: Police
    TORONTO — Four people have been arrested in a shooting in northwest Toronto that sent five people to hospital, one with life-threatening injuries, police said Thursday.

    Four Arrested After Five People Shot In Toronto: Police

    How could cozier U.S.-Cuba relationship affect Canadian business interests?

    How could cozier U.S.-Cuba relationship affect Canadian business interests?
    OTTAWA — Experts believe closer ties between the United States and Cuba will eventually make economic waves for Canadian business.

    How could cozier U.S.-Cuba relationship affect Canadian business interests?

    What does hunger look like in Nunavut? One man's struggle to feed his kids

    What does hunger look like in Nunavut? One man's struggle to feed his kids
    IQALUIT, Nunavut — Israel Mablick's youngest son clings to his neck as another one of his children and his nephew bounce around on a thin mattress stuffed into a cramped space that doubles as a bedroom and a living room.

    What does hunger look like in Nunavut? One man's struggle to feed his kids

    Dalhousie University students face restorative justice for Facebook posts

    Dalhousie University students face restorative justice for Facebook posts
    HALIFAX — Dalhousie University says it is proceeding with a restorative justice process to resolve complaints about sexually violent comments posted on a Facebook group page about female students at its dentistry school.

    Dalhousie University students face restorative justice for Facebook posts

    Rise and fall of Alberta Wildrose party inextricably linked to Danielle Smith

    Rise and fall of Alberta Wildrose party inextricably linked to Danielle Smith
    EDMONTON — Danielle Smith appeared to be heading back to her political roots with Alberta's Progressive Conservatives on Wednesday after spending the last five years fighting to oust them from power.

    Rise and fall of Alberta Wildrose party inextricably linked to Danielle Smith

    U.S.-Cuba deal means end of golden era for Canadian tourists: experts

    U.S.-Cuba deal means end of golden era for Canadian tourists: experts
    TORONTO — The dawn of a new era between the United States and Cuba is poised to spell the end of a golden age for Canadian tourists, experts said Wednesday.

    U.S.-Cuba deal means end of golden era for Canadian tourists: experts

    PrevNext