Wednesday, July 17, 2024
ADVT 
Reviews

Which midsize truck is better? Edmunds compares the Chevrolet Colorado and Ford Ranger

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 05 Jun, 2024 09:43 AM
  • Which midsize truck is better? Edmunds compares the Chevrolet Colorado and Ford Ranger

Buying a midsize truck can be a smart choice if you want a truck that’s capable but less expensive and more maneuverable than the typical full-size truck. There are quite a few options available and among them are two domestic headliners: the Chevrolet Colorado and Ford Ranger.

Both trucks have been recently rdesigned and dramatically improved. They’re also about as evenly matched as you can get, so much so that only one-tenth of a point separates them in Edmunds’ midsize truck rankings. You could be happy with either one yet they differ in small ways that could tip the balance based on your needs. Edmunds’ experts break down the attributes that will help you decide which is best for you.

POWER AND FUEL ECONOMY

The Ranger offers a trio of muscular engines, starting with a 270-horsepower turbocharged four-cylinder, followed by a larger 315-horsepower turbo V6. Even the base engine is surprisingly powerful for standard truck duties; for the true need-for-speed types, there is also off-road-focused Ranger Raptor trim that packs a 405-horsepower turbo V6.

Chevy doesn’t offer quite as extensive of a lineup. The Colorado has just a single turbocharged four-cylinder that produces 237 horsepower; an upgraded version is also available with 310 horsepower. Even the base engine makes plenty of low-end power that’s useful both for towing and keeping pace with city traffic. In Edmunds’ testing, the four-cylinder Ranger and the Colorado with its more powerful engine both accelerated from zero to 60 mph in a quick 6.7 seconds.

At its best, the four-cylinder Ranger gets an EPA-estimated 22 mpg combined in both rear- and four-wheel drive. The Colorado gets slightly lower estimates, with a base four-cylinder rated at 22 mpg combined for rear-wheel drive or 20 mpg combined for four-wheel drive. While the Colorado easily satisfies, the Ranger offers more variety, more power and better efficiency.

Winner: Ranger

TOWING AND PAYLOAD

Properly equipped, the Colorado’s can tow up to 7,700 pounds or haul up to 1,684 pounds. The Ranger tows slightly less — 7,500 pounds — but can haul more at 1,805 pounds. In real terms, both trucks are easily capable of pulling motorcycle trailers, small to midsize camper trailers, or many boats with ease.

There are a few minor differences that give the Ranger an advantage. Both trucks offer available tow packages that come with a trailer brake controller. This is a feature that allows you to adjust your trailer’s brakes from inside the cab. Also, the Ranger’s bed is slightly wider at 48 inches between the wheelwells, enough to fit a standard sheet of plywood. The Colorado’s bed is narrower by about 3 inches.

Winner: Ranger

OFF-ROAD CAPABILITY

Getting a stock truck that can perform in the dirt has never been easier. The Colorado’s Trail Boss trim starts you out with all-terrain tires and a raised suspension, while the ZR2 takes it further with more aggressive tires, upgraded shock absorbers, an even taller stance, and locking front and rear differentials. Chevy also offers a ZR2 Bison Edition that has even bigger tires and additional underbody protection.

For its part, Ford offers just one off-road version: the Ranger Raptor. But with its 405-horsepower engine, big all-terrain tires, and Fox racing-style shocks, the Raptor is a premier dirt and desert runner. The Raptor isn’t built so much for climbing tricky terrain — although it can do that, too — as it is crossing dirt, mud, dust and washboard roads at speed.

Winner: tie

TECHNOLOGY AND VALUE

Inside the cab, the Colorado’s 11.3-inch touchscreen offers more real estate than the Ranger’s 10-inch display, and it’s underpinned by faster Android-based software that includes Google voice assistant. The Ranger offers a larger 12-inch vertical display but it only comes standard on the well-equipped Lariat and Raptor trims. The Ranger also buries some basic functions, such as climate controls, within the touchscreen rather than having them be easier-to-use physical buttons.

The Colorado is also less expensive, at least initially. Pricing starts at $31,095 for a rear-wheel-drive Colorado WT, including destination. For the least expensive Ranger XL, you’re looking at $34,315. There’s a big price difference between the top Colorado ZR2 and Ford Ranger Raptor too. But dig deeper and you’ll notice that Ford generally equips the Ranger’s trim levels with more standard features to justify the price; adding those features through various option packages on the Colorado closes the gap considerably. Ultimately, though, we like that Chevy gives shoppers a lower entry point and more ways to get a truck exactly how they want.

Winner: Colorado

EDMUNDS SAYS

The Ranger tops a majority of the categories in this round-up and stands as Edmunds’ top-rated midsize truck. But this contest is so close that we can easily understand why you’d want to get a Colorado instead.

MORE Reviews ARTICLES

Edmunds: The best used vehicles for young drivers under $20,000

Edmunds: The best used vehicles for young drivers under $20,000
Safety is critically important when choosing a vehicle for a younger driver.  Many parents want to mitigate risk as much as possible when selecting a vehicle for their first-time drivers.

Edmunds: The best used vehicles for young drivers under $20,000

2024 Range Rover Autobiography LWB : A new standard for premium utility vehicles

2024 Range Rover Autobiography LWB : A new standard for premium utility vehicles
The 2024 Range Rover Autobiography LWB (long wheelbase) might just be the most beautiful seven-passenger SUV on the market today.

2024 Range Rover Autobiography LWB : A new standard for premium utility vehicles

2024 Mercedes Benz Eqe 500 Suv : Sporty Electric Crossover

2024 Mercedes Benz Eqe 500 Suv : Sporty Electric Crossover
The Mercedes-Benz EQE 500 SUV is the grade-topping counterpart to the EQE Sedan that offers a performance-oriented zero emissions motoring experience in a crossover form factor.

2024 Mercedes Benz Eqe 500 Suv : Sporty Electric Crossover

Edmunds: The Four Best Auto Deals

Edmunds: The Four Best Auto Deals
Edmunds experts offer their recommendations on how to get the best car, truck and SUV savings throughout the summer. More and more electric vehicles are coming to market, but this increase hasn’t perfectly synced with consumer demand. Some automakers are adjusting their pricing downward to compensate. That’s good news if you’re interested in an EV.  

Edmunds: The Four Best Auto Deals

Edmunds: 2024 Kia Niro versus 2024 Toyota Corolla Cross

Edmunds: 2024 Kia Niro versus 2024 Toyota Corolla Cross
High fuel economy is increasingly a popular desire as well. If this sounds like what you’re looking for in your next vehicle, consider the 2024 Kia Niroor the 2024 Toyota Corolla Cross Hybrid.  Edmunds’ auto experts put these hybrid SUVs head-to-head to see which one offers more for your money.  

Edmunds: 2024 Kia Niro versus 2024 Toyota Corolla Cross

Edmunds picks the best used plug-in hybrids that qualify for the federal tax credit

Edmunds picks the best used plug-in hybrids that qualify for the federal tax credit
The car experts at Edmunds rounded up five of their top used plug-in hybrid picks. The estimated price ranges listed below are what you can typically expect to pay at a nationwide no-haggle dealership such as CarMax or Carvana.

Edmunds picks the best used plug-in hybrids that qualify for the federal tax credit

PrevNext