Saturday, June 20, 2026
ADVT 
Bollywood

2 Historians See No Wrong In 'Padmaavat', Karni Sena Still Gripes

IANS, 30 Jan, 2018 02:12 PM

    Even as two historians claimed that 'Padmaavat' does not hurt sentiments of any caste or community, the Shri Rajput Karni Sena on Tuesday again claimed that historical facts had been tampered with in the movie.

     

    Informed sources said historians R.S. Khangarot, Principal of Agarwal PG College in Jaipur, and Rajasthan University's retired history professor B.L. Gupta watched the movie in Bengaluru in Karnataka on Monday after a special invite by spiritual leader Sri Sri Ravi Shankar at his ashram to watch the movie in an attempt to resolve the raging row over the film.

     

    Khangarot had claimed that the film has nothing to do with history and does not hurt any section of society. Gupta seconded the view and said nothing in the film hurts the sentiments of any particular community.

     

    Karni Sena Spokesperson Vijendra Singh told IANS that these two historians did not watch the movie earlier.

     

    "We need to know in which context they said what they said. Had they questioned the movie's credibility, would Bhansali have stopped its release?" he asked.

     

    "Pregnant women never perform 'jauhar' or self-immolation, as shown in the movie. (Allaudin) Khilji attacked Chittorgarh when he was aged 55, but the movie shows a young Khilji of around 25. The Chittorgarh Fort's door was never broken by Khilji, but the movie shows otherwise," the Karni Sena leader claimed.

     

    He said as per history, Khilji uprooted the fort door and took it along with him to Delhi. "Bharatpur's then king Surajmal brought the door back and reinstalled it at the fort after 400 years. However, the film shows that the door was smashed by Khilji to enter the fort," Vijendra Singh said.

     

    He said in the movie, Khilji is shown entering the fort and threatening Raja Ratan Singh to allow his wife to go with him or else he will be killed right there. "This sounds too comical -- a king can just not be threatened in his own kingdom."

     

    He quoted other scenes also which he claimed were not as per historical facts.

     

    When pointed out the movie is doing well at the Box Office and earning rave reviews too, he quippted: "This is India, where even (former adult movie star) Sunny Leone has a strong fan following."

    MORE Bollywood ARTICLES

    Censor Board Red Flags Amartya Documentary, Filmmakers, Writers Slam Censorship

    Censor Board Red Flags Amartya Documentary, Filmmakers, Writers Slam Censorship
    While the world renowned economist refused to be drawn into the controversy, Ghosh expressed shock over the recommendations of the panel, which held that the words would "damage the country's image".

    Censor Board Red Flags Amartya Documentary, Filmmakers, Writers Slam Censorship

    Women Were Treated As Property: Konkona Sen

    National Award winning actress Konkona Sen Sharma says historically, regardless of class, religion and region, women were always treated as property.

    Women Were Treated As Property: Konkona Sen

    Why Ranbir Finds It 'Challenging' To Work With Anurag Basu

    Why Ranbir Finds It 'Challenging' To Work With Anurag Basu
    Actor Ranbir Kapoor, who has collaborated with Anurag Basu for the second time for "Jagga Jasoos" after "Barfi!", says the challenging part about working with the filmmaker is the patience and the time it takes.

    Why Ranbir Finds It 'Challenging' To Work With Anurag Basu

    Angad Bedi Says Father Bishan Singh Bedi Helped To Prepare For Role

    Actor Angad Bedi, son of former Indian cricketer Bishan Singh Bedi, says his father helped him prepare for his role Arvind Vashishth in "Inside Edge" -- a web series with the backdrop of a cricket tournament.

    Angad Bedi Says Father Bishan Singh Bedi Helped To Prepare For Role

    Sonam Kapoor Set For A 'Talk' Show As Harvard Invites Her For A New 'Gender Series'

    Sonam Kapoor Set For A 'Talk' Show As Harvard Invites Her For A New 'Gender Series'
    Sonam Kapoor says the subject that she is going to speak on “is very relevant to times that we live in.”

    Sonam Kapoor Set For A 'Talk' Show As Harvard Invites Her For A New 'Gender Series'

    He Is A Friend And Brother, I Miss Him: Kapil Sharma On Sunil Grover- Watch Video

    He Is A Friend And Brother, I Miss Him: Kapil Sharma On Sunil Grover- Watch Video
    Replying to queries about Sunil Grover’s return to The Kapil Sharma Show, Kapil told fans that he misses Grover

    He Is A Friend And Brother, I Miss Him: Kapil Sharma On Sunil Grover- Watch Video