Wednesday, June 10, 2026
ADVT 
Bollywood

That Scar Is Permanent, Saeed Mirza On Modi's Gujarat Legacy

IANS, 15 Jun, 2018 01:54 PM
  • That Scar Is Permanent, Saeed Mirza On Modi's Gujarat Legacy
He has been called an angry radical, an anarchist and a lot of other things but multiple award-winning director of films, documentaries and television serials, Saeed Akhtar Mirza is, in his own words, a leftist Sufi. His third book, billed as "a personal history of our times", bears this out.
 
 
"Memory in the Age of Amnesia" (Westland/222 pages/Rs 499) opens with an essay titled "The Gujarat Legacy", in which Mirza lashes out at Prime Minister Narendra Modi -- without naming him -- and sets out to remind his readers of the "scar" that, although permanent, seems to have been overlooked.
 
 
"A man has been installed as the Prime Minister of my country," Mirza writes in the opening chapter of the 222-page book, "who represents a political and ideological mindset that I oppose and find deeply disturbing."
 
 
"His contentious and questionable journey to the pinnacle of power has been documented thoroughly and no amount of wizardry of words and convoluted arguments by admiring political pundits and fans and his own, personal amnesia of what he did to arrive at where he is, can erase that history. The scar is permanent," the 74-year-old notes. 
 
 
Mirza, who divides his time between Mumbai and Goa, nonetheless recognises the fact that Modi "was democratically elected by the people of our country".
 
 
But, Mirza reflects, he swept to power with "such a force that any semblance of a credible opposition has almost completely vanished".
 
 
"His invincibility -- backed by a money-and-media juggernaut -- has since then been at times upstaged and has even faltered in some crucial elections," he writes.
 
 
But this book is not just about Mirza's observations on the current state of affairs; it is rather a recollection of memories that he has lived with and that have shaped his life.
 
 
"The painful conclusion that I draw from his victory was that for the people of India, at least to the 31 per cent who voted for him vehemently, his background didn't matter. For them it was simple: What happened, happened (in Gujarat in 2002).
 
 
"The country had to move on and there was no future in looking over one's shoulder at the past. For these people, it was a memory erased or overlooked," Mirza writes.
 
 
He then goes on to express his shock over those who did not vote for "this demagogue" and asks why couldn't they see the avalanche coming.
 
 
But four years have rolled by since Modi assumed office as the Prime Minister. What is it that Mirza is trying to get at?
 
 
In what he calls an attempt to "jog our collective memories", Mirza travels down memory lane to the time when India became a Republic with a written constitution and our founding fathers defined the nation to the people of India and to the world.
 
 
From here, Mirza moves to "the slow dismantling of the institutions" that, according to him, began within 15 years of our Independence.
 
 
"What followed for the next 30 years were a series of manufactured riots and conflagrations that left the nation reeling," he notes.
 
 
He then trains his guns at the Congress party, which was the dominant party in the initial years of independence when "the seeds of long-term disaster" were sown. Accusing the Congress of harnessing "quite a few right-wing warlords", Mirza contends that it was their "greed for short-term gains" that has led the country to where it is now.
 
 
But is he just imagining these things, another conspiracy theory?
 
 
"I don't think so. I believe we are living in a world where the present looms so disconcertingly large it leaves us little time for reflection. It seems our memory span is getting shorter and what fills our information matrices so often is meaningless trivia," he asserts in the book. 

MORE Bollywood ARTICLES

Had No Administrative Authority In 'Queen' Remake: Tamannaah

Actress Tamannaah Bhatia says she didn't enjoy any administrative authority in the creative role play in the Telugu version of Kangana Ranaut-starrer "Queen".

Had No Administrative Authority In 'Queen' Remake: Tamannaah

Vikram Bhatt An Ocean Full Of Knowledge: Zareen Khan

Vikram Bhatt An Ocean Full Of Knowledge: Zareen Khan
On her experience of working with Bhatt, Zareen told IANS on phone from Mumbai: "It was great. I did not know him on a personal level before this movie. For me, he was a great director, and I have always been a fan of his work." 

Vikram Bhatt An Ocean Full Of Knowledge: Zareen Khan

'Padmaavat' Makers State Disclaimers Loud And Clear Via Ad

'Padmaavat' Makers State Disclaimers Loud And Clear Via Ad
The makers of "Padmaavat", through front page advertisements in newspapers on Monday, listed disclaimers clarifying that it never had a dream sequence featuring Alauddin Khilji and Rani Padmavati, and that it is a movie every Indian will be proud of.

'Padmaavat' Makers State Disclaimers Loud And Clear Via Ad

Bigg Boss 11 Winner Shilpa Shinde: I Don't Want To Meet Hina Khan Again In My Life

Bigg Boss 11 Winner Shilpa Shinde: I Don't Want To Meet Hina Khan Again In My Life
Bigg Boss 11 winner Shilpa Shinde proves that the friends and enemies made inside the house are for keeps. Here is what she has to say about first runner-up Hina Khan and contestants Akash Dadlani and Arshi Khan.

Bigg Boss 11 Winner Shilpa Shinde: I Don't Want To Meet Hina Khan Again In My Life

Bhangra Not Just About Balle Balle, Hoye Hoye: Bally Sagoo

Sagoo believes Bollywood has progressed a lot with new sounds, but not bhangra music.

Bhangra Not Just About Balle Balle, Hoye Hoye: Bally Sagoo

Trending: Madhuri Dixit's First Look From Marathi Debut Bucket List

Trending: Madhuri Dixit's First Look From Marathi Debut Bucket List
Bollywood's evergreen beauty Madhuri Dixit flaunts a simple get-up in a sari in the first look of her Marathi movie debut "Bucket List".

Trending: Madhuri Dixit's First Look From Marathi Debut Bucket List