Monday, June 27, 2022
ADVT 
India

'Hand can also be weapon': SC on 1-year rigorous imprisonment for Navjot Singh Sidhu

Darpan News Desk IANS, 19 May, 2022 10:47 AM
  • 'Hand can also be weapon': SC on 1-year rigorous imprisonment for Navjot Singh Sidhu

New Delhi, May 19 (IANS) The Supreme Court on Thursday held that the hand can also be a weapon by itself where a boxer, cricketer, or a fit person inflicts a blow, as it sentenced Congress' Punjab leader Navjot Singh Sidhu to one year rigorous imprisonment in a 1988 road rage case.

A bench of Justices A.M. Khanwilkar and Sanjay Kishan Kaul said: "The hand can also be a weapon by itself, where, say a boxer, a wrestler or a cricketer or an extremely physically fit person inflicts the same. This may be understood where a blow may be given either by a physically fit person or to a more aged person."

It said there cannot be leniency in sentencing when the hurt/injury has resulted in death, nor can the delay in trial be taken into account which was not attributable to the complainants.

"Respondent No 1 (Sidhu), at the relevant time, was a young man of 25 years, who was playing international cricket and was athletically physically fit. He is expected to know the effect of any blow to be inflicted by him, more so, when on the opposite side the man is aged about 65 years (more than his father's age and elder to him by 40 years)," the bench held.

It said Sidhu cannot say that he did not know the effect of the blow or plead ignorance on this aspect. It further added that it is not as if someone has to remind him of the extent of the injury which could be caused by a blow inflicted by him. "In the given circumstances, tempers may have been lost but then the consequences of the loss of temper must be borne," said the bench.

The top court noted it was urged that simply because it was a spontaneous incident where no weapon was used, but held that this cannot be a ground to inflict minimal and innocuous punishment of fine of Rs 1,000.

It said the question is whether even on sentence, mere passage of time can result in a fine of Rs 1,000, being an adequate sentence where a person has lost his life by reason of the severity of the blow inflicted by Sidhu with his hands.

"Insofar as the injury caused is concerned, this court has accepted the plea of a single blow by hand being given on the head of the deceased. In our view, it is this significance which is an error apparent on the face of the record needing some remedial action, added the bench.

On aspect of sentence in the matter, it said: "Punishments are awarded not because of the fact that it has to be an eye for an eye or a tooth for a tooth, rather having its due impact on the society; while undue harshness is not required but inadequate punishment may lead to sufferance of the community at large."

MORE India ARTICLES

Woman lost during 1947 violence meets Sikh brothers after 75 yrs at Kartarpur

Woman lost during 1947 violence meets Sikh brothers after 75 yrs at Kartarpur

At the time of the Partition, Mumtaz Bibi was an infant who was lying on her mother's dead body who was killed by the violent mobs, Dawn news reported. One Muhammad Iqbal and his wife, Allah Rakhi, adopted the infant and raised her as their own daughter, naming her Mumtaz Bibi.

Woman lost during 1947 violence meets Sikh brothers after 75 yrs at Kartarpur

Punjab farmers end protest on Chandigarh borders; consensus on demands

Punjab farmers end protest on Chandigarh borders; consensus on demands

The meeting between the Chief Minister and leaders of 23 farmers' unions under the banner of the Sanyukt Kisan Morcha that lasted for over two and half hours here.

Punjab farmers end protest on Chandigarh borders; consensus on demands

Stop eviction of villagers, SC panel directs Punjab

Stop eviction of villagers, SC panel directs Punjab

Besides, the NCSC also asked the government to stop the eviction drive and maintain status quo. In a complaint to the NCSC, residents of Bhama Kalan village said they have possession of 200 acres in the village since 1947.

Stop eviction of villagers, SC panel directs Punjab

Karti named in FIR, Rs 50 lakh bribe paid to help Chinese nationals: CBI

Karti named in FIR, Rs 50 lakh bribe paid to help Chinese nationals: CBI

Talwandi Sabo Power Limited, a private firm based in Mansa, took the help of a middleman and allegedly paid Rs 50 lakh to get the visa issued for the Chinese nationals which would help it in completing a project before the deadline, according to the CBI.

Karti named in FIR, Rs 50 lakh bribe paid to help Chinese nationals: CBI

Amarinder reminds AAP of opposing extension of BSF jurisdiction

Amarinder reminds AAP of opposing extension of BSF jurisdiction

The former Chief Minister hoped the state government, instead of adopting a confrontationist attitude, will co-operate and co-ordinate with the Central government to handle all the security and other issues Punjab is challenged with.

Amarinder reminds AAP of opposing extension of BSF jurisdiction

After Delhi, Punjab farmers gather on Chandigarh borders over demands

After Delhi, Punjab farmers gather on Chandigarh borders over demands

As the year-long protest against the Centre's farm laws at the Delhi borders ended in November last year with the revoking of the three Central farm laws, hundreds of Punjab farmers on Tuesday gathered on the outskirts of the state capital demanding compensation of Rs 500 per quintal for those who suffered losses due to early onset of early summer.

After Delhi, Punjab farmers gather on Chandigarh borders over demands

PrevNext