Saturday, December 20, 2025
ADVT 
India

Modi's Jibe At Upa In Canada Regrettable, Disgraceful: Shashi Tharoor

Darpan News Desk IANS, 19 Apr, 2015 03:03 PM
    Prime Minister Narendra Modi's jibe at the previous UPA government during his Canada trip, saying he would "clean up the dirt" left behind by them, was "regrettable" and "nothing less than disgraceful", Congress MP Shashi Tharoor said here on Sunday.
     
    "Saying that abroad was not healthy. Political speechifying is normal in any democracy, but you do it at home. We have always held the view that our political differences should stop at the waters' edge. And that's why it was rather regrettable that the prime minister spoke in that way about his predecessors," Tharoor told IANS here.
     
    During his speech to the Indian diaspora at the Ricoh Coliseum in Toronto on April 16, Modi had promised to "clean up" the "dirt" left behind by the previous government and said there is a new atmosphere of trust in India.
     
    People cheered him when Modi, while referring to his mission to clean India and root out corruption, said in Hindi: "Jinhone gandgi karni thee, woh kar ke chale gaye. Lekin hum safai kar ke jayenge (Those who created scams and dirt have now gone, we will clean up the mess)."
     
    The prime minister drew the biggest applause when he said his mission is "Skill India while their's was Scam India".
     
    Tharoor said: "After all, the leaders he (Modi) is meeting have also met the leaders who were his predecessors, and it is rather insulting. Imagine if I come to you and say: 'Ah, the previous person who was in my job was a useless chap'. that is not a nice thing to do to an outsider. And I think that really was nothing less than disgraceful."
     
    The Congress has also contested Modi's claim that his Canada visit was the first bilateral by an Indian prime minister in 42 years. The party says former prime minister Manmohan Singh went to Canada in 2010. 
     
    The Modi government cl-ims it was the first "stand alone visit".
     
    Tharoor said: "How does stand-alone matter. The statement made was that it was the first visit to Canada in 42 years, which is factually incorrect. And they also tried to explain it was a bilateral visit, and that Manmohan Singh's was allegedly a G20 visit; but the truth is that Manmohan Singh did both the G20 and the bilateral with the Canadian prime minister. 
     
    "You can go on the website of prime minister of Canada, there is an account of the bilateral, the word 'bilateral' is used, summit between the two of them. So stand-alone is a peculiar concept; neither Anand Sharma and I, who have both been ministers in the external affairs ministry, see much of a distinction there. It's a question of whether you have had a bilateral visit or not; and yes we have had it five years ago."

    MORE India ARTICLES

    Black money issue rocks parliament

    Black money issue rocks parliament
    The issue of black money rocked the Lok Sabha on the first working day of parliament's winter session Tuesday, as several opposition parties tried to corner....

    Black money issue rocks parliament

    Voting begins in Kashmir assembly polls

    Voting begins in Kashmir assembly polls
    Balloting began Tuesday in 15 assembly constituencies in the first of the five-phase elections in Jammu and Kashmir, officials said....

    Voting begins in Kashmir assembly polls

    New style of governance with iron hand

    New style of governance with iron hand
    In the six months he has ruled India, Prime Minister Narendra Modi has demonstrated a new style of governance, of a "taskmaster" in his own words, peppered...

    New style of governance with iron hand

    Historical fiction looks at 1984 anti-Sikh riots

    Historical fiction looks at 1984 anti-Sikh riots
    The wounds of the victims of one of the darkest periods of recent history haven't healed yet, and there is constant struggle to seek closure says an author-journalist ...

    Historical fiction looks at 1984 anti-Sikh riots

    Modi leaves for SAARC Tuesday, meeting with Sharif not ruled out

    Modi leaves for SAARC Tuesday, meeting with Sharif not ruled out
    A likely meeting between Prime Minster Narendra Modi and his Pakistani counterpart Nawaz Sharif on the sidelines of the SAARC summit has lent added...

    Modi leaves for SAARC Tuesday, meeting with Sharif not ruled out

    Nepal-India border to be sealed during Modi visit

    Nepal-India border to be sealed during Modi visit
    Some parts of the Nepal-India border will be sealed during Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi's visit to Lumbini, the birthplace of Lord Buddha, an official said here Saturday....

    Nepal-India border to be sealed during Modi visit