Sunday, August 18, 2019
ADVT 
India

Woman Driven Out Of Matrimonial House Can File Case Anywhere: Top Court

Darpan News Desk IANS, 09 Apr, 2019
  • Woman Driven Out Of Matrimonial House Can File Case Anywhere: Top Court

Women can file matrimonial cases, including criminal matters pertaining to cruelty, from the place where they have taken shelter after leaving or being driven out of their matrimonial home, the Supreme Court said on Tuesday.


The apex court's verdict came on an appeal filed by Rupali Devi against the Allahabad High Court which dismissed her plea to file a dowry harassment case from her parents' house.


The high court order held that cruelty punishable under Section 498A of the IPC is not a continuing offence, and thus cannot be investigated or punished in a jurisdiction outside the one in which the matrimonial house of the complainant is situated.


A bench headed by Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi said the impact on the mental health of the wife by "overt acts" by the husband or his relatives, mental stress and trauma of being driven away from the matrimonial home cannot be ignored while understanding the meaning of "cruelty" in Section 498A of the Indian Penal Code.


"We, therefore, hold that the courts at the place where the wife takes shelter after leaving or driven away from the matrimonial home on account of acts of cruelty committed by the husband or his relatives, would, dependent on the factual situation, also have jurisdiction to entertain a complaint alleging commission of offences under Section 498A of the IPC", said the bench, also comprising Justices L Nageswara Rao and S K Kaul.


The top court said that Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act provides a civil remedy to victims, as against the remedy in criminal law which is what is provided under Section 498A (subjecting married woman to cruelty by her spouse and in-laws) of the Indian Penal Code.


The provisions contained in Section 498A undoubtedly encompasses both mental as well as the physical well-being of the wife, it said.


"Even the silence of the wife may have an underlying element of an emotional distress and mental agony. Her sufferings at the parental home though may be directly attributable to commission of acts of cruelty by the husband at the matrimonial home would, undoubtedly, be the consequences of the acts committed at the matrimonial home," the bench said.


"Such consequences, by itself, would amount to distinct offences committed at the parental home where she has taken shelter. The adverse effects on the mental health in the parental home though on account of the acts committed in the matrimonial home would, in our considered view, amount to commission of cruelty within the meaning of Section 498A at the parental home," it added.

MORE India ARTICLES

Ahead Of Baisakhi, Pakistan To Issue Visas To 2,200 Sikh Pilgrims

Ahead Of Baisakhi, Pakistan To Issue Visas To 2,200 Sikh Pilgrims

Pakistan's High Commissioner Sohail Mahmood said the gesture by Pakistan to issue these visas was reflective of the reverence attached to Baisakhi.

 

Ahead Of Baisakhi, Pakistan To Issue Visas To 2,200 Sikh Pilgrims

It's Welcome: Rajinikanth On BJP's Poll Promise Of Interlinking Rivers

It's Welcome: Rajinikanth On BJP's Poll Promise Of Interlinking Rivers

Interlinking of rivers is among the promises made in the BJP's manifesto for the 2019 Lok Sabha polls released on Monday by Prime Minister Narendra Modi.

It's Welcome: Rajinikanth On BJP's Poll Promise Of Interlinking Rivers

We Will Come Out Stronger In Punjab, Says AAP Lawmaker Bhagwant Mann

We Will Come Out Stronger In Punjab, Says AAP Lawmaker Bhagwant Mann

Lok Sabha Elections 2019: "Our performance in the Lok Sabha polls will be better than the last general elections," said Bhagwant Mann.

We Will Come Out Stronger In Punjab, Says AAP Lawmaker Bhagwant Mann

UK's Expression Of Regret Will Help In Jallianwala Bagh Closure: Minister Hardeep Puri

UK's Expression Of Regret Will Help In Jallianwala Bagh Closure: Minister Hardeep Puri

"I think some form of expression would be in order. But I am saying this in my personal capacity. Government of India's stand is to be articulated by the Ministry of External Affairs or anyone else," Hardeep Puri said.

UK's Expression Of Regret Will Help In Jallianwala Bagh Closure: Minister Hardeep Puri

9 Heads Of Congress State Units Wanted Me To Campaign: Navjot Sidhu

9 Heads Of Congress State Units Wanted Me To Campaign: Navjot Sidhu

Navjot Singh Sidhu is expected to campaign for the party for 40 days starting April 10.

 

9 Heads Of Congress State Units Wanted Me To Campaign: Navjot Sidhu

Travesty Of Justice: CBI Opposes Sajjan Kumar's Bail Plea In 1984 Case

Travesty Of Justice: CBI Opposes Sajjan Kumar's Bail Plea In 1984 Case

Former Congress leader Sajjan Kumar was convicted and sentenced to life in a 1984 Anti-Sikh riots case.

Travesty Of Justice: CBI Opposes Sajjan Kumar's Bail Plea In 1984 Case

PrevNext