Monday, June 29, 2026
ADVT 
International

'Anti-National' Poet Mirza Ghalib Defends Self

IANS, 26 May, 2017 11:22 PM
    Mirza Ghalib in the times of terrorism? The 19th century bard having to defend himself against charges of anti-nationalism in a modern-day court? A new play has done just that — plucking the 19th century poet out of history and placing him in contemporary times.
     
    In the play “Anti-National Ghalib”, staged here recently, the poet is summoned by a court after a plaintiff alleges that he had “hurt religious sentiments and threatened national security”.
     
    “These days, people are trying to create arguments out of nothing,” says author-director Danish Iqbal, explaining what prompted him to write the play. “The trend of frivolous litigations is growing,” he adds.
     
    The plot revolves around a filmmaker, who, desperate to delay the release of his rival’s film, alleges that it features lyrics, originally penned by Ghalib, that are offensive.
     
    The bone of contention is Ghalib’s famous lines: “Na suno gar bura kahe koi/ na kaho gar bura kare koi” (If someone speaks ill, pay no heed; if someone behaves sinfully, stay silent) and “Ibn-e-Maryam hua kare koi mere dukh ki dava kare koi” (Let anyone the son of Mary be/How will I know till they find the remedy).
     
    The plaintiff alleges that at a time when the government is adopting new methods to tap conversations of terrorist groups, Ghalib, through his words, is urging people to turn a blind eye to evil deeds.
     
    “His lyrics compromise our national security and also hurt the religious sentiments of Christians,” the plaintiff says.
     
    But the plot thickens as the trial transforms into a ‘mushaira’, much to the chagrin of the petitioner.
     
    Ghalib also finds that he has to defend himself against accusations that were hurled at him in the past — of being a drunkard and having an extra-marital affair. But it is his defence against debt that leaves the audience in splits.
     
    Ghalib, who had a debt of Rs 12,000, says he will repay the money to his creditors once popular artistes such as Begum Akhtar and Jagjit Singh, who often sang his songs, pay him royalty.
     
    “They have made crores by singing my verses, without giving me anything. Whereas in my time I was told to pay four times the amount that I had taken in debt. Tell them to pay the money they owe me, and you can then deduct my debt from it,” he says.
     
    To strengthen the prosecution’s case, Ghalib’s rival poet, Muhammad Ibrahim Zauq, is presented in court as a witness. It is clear that there is no love lost between the two, even after their death around 150 years ago.
     
    “Do I have the permission to recite your couplet?” asks Ghalib, to which the inimitable Zauq replies, “Please do. Anyway no one understands yours.”
     
    The play also takes a sarcastic dig at people’s scanty knowledge of Urdu. Ghalib recites “Koi misra toh uthao” (someone repeat the first line of the couplet). A confused judge orders a court official by the name of Mishra to leave the room. 
     
    “This is comedy done very seriously,” Iqbal explains. “The attempt is not to enact a comedy, but to laugh at ourselves and at ongoing societal trends,” he says.

    MORE International ARTICLES

    Prosecutors seek new conviction for William Melchert-Dinkel who aided Canadian's suicide

    Prosecutors seek new conviction for William Melchert-Dinkel who aided Canadian's suicide
    Prosecutors argued Friday that a former nurse should be convicted of assisting suicide for sending emails and other online communications in which he urged two people in Canada and Britain to kill themselves and gave them information on how to do it.

    Prosecutors seek new conviction for William Melchert-Dinkel who aided Canadian's suicide

    Tropical Storm Iselle makes landfall on Hawaii; Topples trees and knocks out power

    Tropical Storm Iselle makes landfall on Hawaii; Topples trees and knocks out power
    HONOLULU, Hawaii - The National Weather Service says the eye of Tropical Storm Iselle has made landfall on Hawaii's Big Island.

    Tropical Storm Iselle makes landfall on Hawaii; Topples trees and knocks out power

    Can Gay Games in US Reduce Barriers Between Gay, Straight People

    Can Gay Games in US Reduce Barriers Between Gay, Straight People
    If Cleveland and Akron seem like odd choices to host the international Gay Games, that's because they are. The eight previous hosts for this quadrennial affair have been gay-friendly cities where those who identify themselves as lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgendered feel comfortable.

    Can Gay Games in US Reduce Barriers Between Gay, Straight People

    Afghan candidates agree to resolve dispute; will name new president by end of August

    Afghan candidates agree to resolve dispute; will name new president by end of August
    KABUL - Afghanistan's feuding presidential candidates agreed Friday to resolve their election dispute and said they would set an inauguration date before the end of August.

    Afghan candidates agree to resolve dispute; will name new president by end of August

    Testing after B.C. mine tailings spill shows metals within water guidelines

    Testing after B.C. mine tailings spill shows metals within water guidelines
    LIKELY, B.C. - The water in a pristine British Columbia lake and river that were flooded with mine waste after a tailing ponds dam burst earlier this week is well within drinking water and aquatic life guidelines, according to preliminary test results announced Thursday.

    Testing after B.C. mine tailings spill shows metals within water guidelines

    GM recalls SUVs for Third Time: Power Window Switches can Short-circuit and Catch Fire

    GM recalls SUVs for Third Time: Power Window Switches can Short-circuit and Catch Fire
    General Motors' troubles with safety recalls have surfaced in another case, this time with the company recalling a group of SUVs for a third time to fix power window switches that can catch fire.

    GM recalls SUVs for Third Time: Power Window Switches can Short-circuit and Catch Fire