Tuesday, December 30, 2025
ADVT 
International

Donald Trump's Canada-Like Merit-Based Immigration Proposal Could Benefit Indians

IANS, 01 Mar, 2017 12:42 PM
    US President Donald Trump's proposal for a merit-based immigration system has the potential to benefit Indians, a large number of whom have high levels of education and skills.
     
    But this will ultimately depend on the finer details of how the proposal is implemented.
     
    In his State of the Union Address to a joint session of Congress on Tuesday night, Trump said the US should give out green cards using a merit-based system similar to those of Canada and Australia in place of its current "outdated" programme.
     
    "Nations around the world, like Canada, Australia and many others -- have a merit-based immigration system," he said. 
     
    "It is a basic principle that those seeking to enter a country ought to be able to support themselves financially."
     
    By not following such a system, he said the US was "straining the very public resources that our poorest citizens rely upon.
     
    "Switching away from this current system of lower-skilled immigration, and instead adopting a merit-based system, will have many benefits: it will save countless dollars, raise workers' wages, and help struggling families -- including immigrant families -- enter the middle class," he said.
     
    Trump did not make any mention of those working in the US on temporary professional work visas known as H-1B. 
     
    In earlier speeches, he had said that he would root out abuses in that visa category and restrict them if they were to throw Americans out of work.
     
     
    Those who qualify for H1-B visas under more stringent conditions either imposed by the Trump Administration or by a bill introduced jointly by a Republican and a Democratic in Congress would likely have a leg up in the merit system.
     
    Any drastic reform of the immigration process will be a difficult undertaking for Trump.
     
    Trump did not spell out how the merit-based system would work.
     
    On the face of it, Indians would make a good fit for a merit-based system going by the community's current profile. 
     
    According to a report by the Pew Research Center, 70 percent of Indians in the US are college graduates. 
     
    The US Census Bureau reported that in 2013, the median household income for Indian families was over $100,000.
     
    But there are other factors such as whether the current national quotas or limits on people from any country who could be admitted in a year are retained could ultimately determine how it plays out for Indians.
     
    The proposal will have to clear many hurdles. 
     
    First of all, it will run into opposition mainly from the Democratic Party which would argue that it would not help the poor and the unskilled immigrate to the US and discriminate against immigrants from Latin American countries whom the party counts as a key part of its base.
     
    A way out for Trump might be to barter the merit-based reform for allowing some illegal immigrants to stay on in the country.
     
    In Canada, applicants for immigration are given points for different qualifications like education, skill levels, employability, language and family ties. 
     
     
    They would have to meet a minimum score to be allowed to immigrate.
     
    Currently, the US immigration system restricts the number of people who can immigrate from each country to seven percent of the total number allowed in except for immediate relatives of citizens. 
     
    This has led to several years' wait for Indians to get their green cards.
     
    There is also an annual limit of 140,000 on employment-based green cards.
     
    Because of the limits, most professionals from India have to wait as long as 12 years for a green card and those with "exceptional qualifications" nine years, according to the State Department visa availability data for March.
     
    A merit-based system has the potential to cut down the wait.
     
    How the reform would ultimately affect Indians could depend on how country limits and the cap on the number of employment visas are retained or handled and also on the retention of the immigration privileges for brothers and sisters of citizens and their families.
     
    The reform may also affect the ability of brothers and sisters and elderly parents of citizens to immigrate if they are subjected to a points system.
     
     
    "I believe that real and positive immigration reform is possible as long as we focus on the following goals: to improve jobs and wages for Americans, to strengthen our nation's security, and to restore respect for our laws," Trump said.
     
    He appealed to the Democrats for bipartisan support for immigration reform. 
     
    "If we are guided by the well-being of American citizens, then I believe Republicans and Democrats can work together to achieve an outcome that has eluded our country for decades," he said.

    MORE International ARTICLES

    India Growing At 8 Per Cent, Why US Is Not: Donald Trump Asks Supporters

    India Growing At 8 Per Cent, Why US Is Not: Donald Trump Asks Supporters
    Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump on Friday criticised outgoing President Barack Obama for leading a slow economic growth, arguing that if a "large country" like India can grow at eight per cent, why the US is not.

    India Growing At 8 Per Cent, Why US Is Not: Donald Trump Asks Supporters

    Baby 'Born Twice' After Miracle Surgery In US

    Baby 'Born Twice' After Miracle Surgery In US
    A baby girl in the US was successfully 'born' for the second time, after being taken out of her mother's womb for 20 minutes at 23 weeks of pregnancy for a groundbreaking surgery to save her life.

    Baby 'Born Twice' After Miracle Surgery In US

    Pakistan uses force to thwart ‘Black Day’ protests in PoK

    Pakistan uses force to thwart ‘Black Day’ protests in PoK
    On this day in 1947, Pakistan had violated all international norms and had sent tribals to invade Kashmir, since then this day has been marked as Black Day every year.

    Pakistan uses force to thwart ‘Black Day’ protests in PoK

    Iconic ‘Afghan girl’ arrested By Pakistan for forged ID card, UNHCR distances itself From Issue

    Iconic ‘Afghan girl’ arrested By Pakistan for forged ID card, UNHCR distances itself From Issue
    The United Nation's refugee agency in Pakistan claimed that Sharbat Gula - known as Afghanistan's green-eyed Mona Lisa - is not a registered refugee.

    Iconic ‘Afghan girl’ arrested By Pakistan for forged ID card, UNHCR distances itself From Issue

    JeM Chief Masood Azhar Is A 'Terrorist', Says Pervez Musharraf

    Former Pakistan President General Pervez Musharraf has described Jaish-e-Mohammed chief Masood Azhar as a "terrorist", saying he has been involved in bomb blasts even in his country.

    JeM Chief Masood Azhar Is A 'Terrorist', Says Pervez Musharraf

    Kashmir A Matter For India, Pak To Sort Out: British PM Theresa May

    The issue was raised in the House of Commons during the weekly Prime Minister's Questions session on Wednesday by Pakistani-born Labour lawmaker Yasmin Qureshi

    Kashmir A Matter For India, Pak To Sort Out: British PM Theresa May