Close X
Sunday, December 8, 2024
ADVT 
International

Presidents and prime ministers: How cross-border personality clashes could play out

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 23 Oct, 2024 04:33 PM
  • Presidents and prime ministers: How cross-border personality clashes could play out

President John F. Kennedy stood before Canadian lawmakers elucidating the important relationship between the two countries: "Geography has made us neighbours. History has made us friends. Economics has made us partners."

"And necessity has made us allies," Kennedy said in a 1961 address to Parliament. 

But behind the scenes, the relationship between the charismatic Kennedy and then-prime minister John Diefenbaker was toxic.

With the looming United States election, the future of who will be at the helm of the bilateral relationship remains unclear, but Canada cannot escape the geopolitical pull of its closest neighbour.

While some presidents and prime ministers have been on friendly terms, the shared geography and history hasn't stopped clashes between others.

"We have a long history of presidents and prime ministers hating each other's guts... and yet the system works,” said Aaron Ettinger, a political science professor at Carleton University.

Experts say incompatible personalities won’t irreparably harm the relationship, but it can make it harder for Canada. 

"It's very difficult to operate when you have outright antagonism between the leaders — and that is less a function of ideology and more a function of personality," said Laura Dawson, an expert on Canada-U. S. relations and the executive director of the Future Borders Coalition.

That became clear during the first Trump administration when the former president scrapped the North American Free Trade Agreement. Negotiations of it's replacement, the Canada-U.S.-Mexico Agreement, were marked by public spats between Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and former president Donald Trump.

Trump called Trudeau "weak" and "dishonest" after the prime minister criticized the president's 2018 tariff actions at the G7 summit in Quebec. 

Robert Lighthizer, Trump's trade representative, recounted in his book that U.S.-Canada relations were "at their lowest ebb since the failed American invasion of Upper Canada during the War of 1812."

The following year there was another blow-up when Trudeau and other NATO leaders appeared to be on video talking about a Trump press conference. The former president called the prime minister "two-faced."

While the relationship between the leaders was publicly rocky, behind the scenes CUSMA was successfully negotiated. Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland called the agreement a "victory for all Canadians," and experts say it was more moderate than Trump originally threatened.

Whoever takes the White House will be in charge during trade pact's 2026 review.

Trudeau is a political veteran now, Dawson said, and is more prepared for a possible second Trump administration.

"We know that Trump-Trudeau is not a good fit," Dawson said. "But I'm sure that Trudeau will figure out a way to make it work." 

Most experts say Kamala Harris' personality would be a better match with Trudeau. It's been reported they already have a good relationship and many of their policy goals align. He originally ran on "sunny ways" and she kicked off her campaign with "joy."

The vice-president also spent part of her youth living in Canada, although observers say the impact of her teenage years in Montreal is probably overstated.

"Harris would obviously be easier for probably anyone to get along with," Dawson said. "But getting along only goes so far."

Harris has been campaigning on her vote against CUSMA, saying it didn't do enough to protect U.S. workers, and is expected to follow the Biden administration's Buy American procurement rules. 

There's another outcome to consider: a change in Canadian leadership. A general election must be held by October next year, but it could come sooner if the Liberals lose the confidence of the House.

The Conservatives have long held a lead in the polls amid high inflation, an exodus of Liberal ministers and uncertainty over Trudeau's political future.

"We have a whole lot of turnover in the works coming up in the next two years between Canada and the United States," Ettinger said. "And it's possible that we have two leaders who have never met one another."

It's not clear how Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre would get along with either presidential candidate. 

Ivan Ivanov, an assistant professor at the University of Ottawa, said Poilievre "is a professional communicator." The expert in public relations and crisis management said the Conservative leader can be combative — which could hurt or help the bilateral relationship — but it plays well among Canadian voters.

During President Joe Biden's state visit to Canada last year he met with Poilievre and they discussed Canadian exemptions to Buy America rules, national defence interests and other issues. A photo shared on Poilievre’s social media shows the leaders shaking hands. 

However, Ettinger said he doesn't think we can "glean much about how he personally will interact with other leaders on the international stage." 

"He’s a complete cipher."

Poilievre's promises share some insight. He pledged to match American tariffs on Chinese-produced electric vehicles a few weeks before the Liberal government took action this summer and promised to push Americans on the longstanding softwood lumber dispute.

Poilievre has also been known to use slogans in the Republican lexicon. For example, Poilievre said he will "replace woke culture with warrior culture" in the military and that "biological males" should not be in women's sports and change rooms — both talking points were included in multiple speeches at the recent Republican National Convention.

But that doesn’t necessarily make him the better match for Trump, Dawson said. 

"We might think that a Poilievre-Trump pairing would be better because he's got a more ideological fit," Dawson said. 

"But we know that Trump is not a traditional Republican at all."

 

MORE International ARTICLES

Divine intervention and saving the economy: What motivates Trump supporters in 2024

Divine intervention and saving the economy: What motivates Trump supporters in 2024
They are known for wearing bright red and showing unwavering allegiance to Donald Trump. The true supporters who are showing up to his hours-long rallies are everyday Americans, convinced that freedom and the future of America are at stake if the former Republican president doesn't win the razor-thin race to the White House.

Divine intervention and saving the economy: What motivates Trump supporters in 2024

US says Indian probe team's visit reflects New Delhi's serious intent

US says Indian probe team's visit reflects New Delhi's serious intent
The US alleged in an indictment filed in a New York court in 2023 that an Indian businessman tried to plot an assassination attempt on a Khalistan separatist -- Gurpatwant Singh Pannun, although he was not named in the court filing -- at the behest of an Indian Central government employee.

US says Indian probe team's visit reflects New Delhi's serious intent

JD Vance and Tim Walz to face off during U.S. vice-presidential debate

JD Vance and Tim Walz to face off during U.S. vice-presidential debate
Tim Walz and JD Vance will face off on the debate stage Tuesday evening in a matchup that both their parties are hoping will demonstrate their vice-presidential candidate's ability to connect with voters in battleground states that will play a critical role in deciding the U.S. election in November.

JD Vance and Tim Walz to face off during U.S. vice-presidential debate

9/11 anniversary brings Biden, Harris and Trump together at ground zero

9/11 anniversary brings Biden, Harris and Trump together at ground zero
The attacks killed 2,977 people and left thousands of bereaved relatives and scarred survivors. The planes took down the World Trade Center’s twin towers and carved a gash in the Pentagon, the U.S. military headquarters.

9/11 anniversary brings Biden, Harris and Trump together at ground zero

Experts say Harris dominated in debate performance against Trump

Experts say Harris dominated in debate performance against Trump
Political experts say Kamala Harris was able to dominate Donald Trump by prodding the former Republican president over the crowd sizes at his rallies and the 2020 loss during a debate in Philadelphia Tuesday evening. Tuesday’s matchup saw Harris push the former president on his record and bait him into tirades far from Trump's intended goals of focusing on immigration and the economy.

Experts say Harris dominated in debate performance against Trump

Harris-Trump US presidential debate offers different visions for America's future

Harris-Trump US presidential debate offers different visions for America's future
Kamala Harris and Donald Trump made their case to American voters during a debate in Philadelphia, during which the Democratic vice president and former Republican president laid out different visions for America's future. Tuesday’s matchup saw Harris push forcefully against the former president on his record, while also prodding at Trump's crowd sizes and 2020 loss to President Joe Biden. 

Harris-Trump US presidential debate offers different visions for America's future

PrevNext