Thursday, January 1, 2026
ADVT 
National

Adjudicator rules in Indigenous health case

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 20 Aug, 2020 07:09 PM
  • Adjudicator rules in Indigenous health case

A human rights adjudicator has ruled that the Manitoba government discriminated against a disabled Indigenous boy by not providing adequate health care.

The province has been ordered to pay the boy and his mother $42,500.

The case centres on Alfred (Dewey) Pruden, who was 16 years old when his human rights complaint was heard last year.

Pruden was born with a neurological disorder, is on the autism spectrum, and suffers from vision loss and poor motor skills.

The hearing was told the province provided some health care services, but denied others on the basis that the federal government is responsible for health care in First Nations communities.

Adjudicator Robert Dawson ruled Pruden did not get the care he needed, because of the jurisdictional divide between the federal and provincial governments.

"No government or other official intended to treat the complainants differently by reason of their ancestry as Anishinaabe people," Dawson wrote in his 20-page decision.

"However, that was the very effect of the whole of the assorted policies, practices, and even laws that try to carve out the concurrent jurisdiction of the federal and provincial governments in respect of health care and related services for First Nations people living in First Nations communities."

Dawson said the end result was that Pruden, who's a member of the Pinaymootang First Nation, 220 kilometres northwest of Winnipeg, received less help than a non-Indigenous person in his situation would have.

"Those intergovernmental arrangements caused health care and related services to be denied, delayed, or intermittently interrupted for the complainants. The same problems did not afflict neighbouring non-First Nations communities and those residents enjoyed health care and related services without denial, delay, or interruption."

The complainants had sought more money, including $200,000 in estimated future lost wages for the mother, who had changed jobs to have more time to care for her son. The adjudicator rejected that request.

MORE National ARTICLES

Museum of Surrey’s Latest Exhibition Explores How We’re All Connected to the Arctic

A scientific and cultural journey to the Arctic is the theme of a new travelling exhibition opening Thursday, March 5 at the Museum of Surrey.

Museum of Surrey’s Latest Exhibition Explores How We’re All Connected to the Arctic

Decade-Long Health Care Battle Draws To A Close Today In British Columbia

Dr. Brian Day began his battle a decade ago against the British Columbia government.    

Decade-Long Health Care Battle Draws To A Close Today In British Columbia

Pipeline Talks With Hereditary Chiefs Resume For Second Day In Northern B.C.

SMITHERS, B.C. - The hereditary chiefs of the Wet'suwet'en meet for a second day with senior federal and provincial ministers today as they try to break an impasse in a pipeline dispute that's sparked national protests and led to disruptions in the economy.

Pipeline Talks With Hereditary Chiefs Resume For Second Day In Northern B.C.

PICS: Sikh One Billion Rising Seva Initiative Prepares 2,300 Care Packages Across Canada

One Billion Rising began as a call to action based on the staggering statistic that 1 in 3 women on the planet will be beaten or raped during her lifetime. With the world population at 7 billion, this adds up to more than one billion women and girls.

PICS: Sikh One Billion Rising Seva Initiative Prepares 2,300 Care Packages Across Canada

World Sikh Organization Welcomes Tabling of Sikh Genocide Awareness Week Bill in Ontario Legislature

The Bill recognizes that Sikhs continue to be impacted by the genocide and other atrocity crimes perpetrated by the Government of India both in 1984 and in the decade that followed.

World Sikh Organization Welcomes Tabling of Sikh Genocide Awareness Week Bill in Ontario Legislature

Tejwant Danjou’s Guilty Plea Withdrawn In Rama Guaravarapu Murder Trial

BC Supreme Court in Kelowna on Friday allowed Tejwant Danjou, 70, a real estate agent from Surrey to withdraw his guilty plea in the second-degree murder of Rama Guaravarapu.

Tejwant Danjou’s Guilty Plea Withdrawn In Rama Guaravarapu Murder Trial