Monday, May 20, 2019
ADVT 
National

B.C. Court Overturns Murder Conviction, Orders New Trial Based Judge's Answer

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 09 Feb, 2019
  • B.C. Court Overturns Murder Conviction, Orders New Trial Based Judge's Answer

VANCOUVER — British Columbia's top court has overturned a second-degree murder conviction against a man who was found guilty of stabbing a Good Samaritan in downtown Vancouver.


The Appeal Court of British Columbia ordered a new trial in the case of Kenneth Williams, who was handed a life sentence in June 2017 with no chance of parole for 10 years.


B.C. Supreme Court heard 28-year-old Robert Smith was killed when he got out of a cab and tried to intervene in a fight that broke out between the driver and Williams after Williams hit or kicked the vehicle while walking down the street.


The Appeal Court says the trial judge's failure to respond adequately to a question from the jury amounted to a miscarriage of justice.


The ruling says Williams relied on a defence of intoxication to raise a reasonable doubt about whether he intended to stab Smith to death.


It says that while the issue of Williams having drank a considerable amount of alcohol on the evening of the alleged offence was not contested, there was no direct evidence regarding his activities during a 90-minute period between when he left a restaurant and the stabbing.


During their deliberations, jurors asked if they could consider whether Williams continued to drink during that period and the role, if any, the "unaccounted-for time" could play in their decision-making.


"The trial judge failed to answer the jury’s question correctly and completely," Justice Gregory Fitch wrote in the Appeal Court decision.


It says the judge's reply that it was up to jurors to draw whatever inferences they chose prejudiced Williams's intoxication defence and was unlikely to resolve their confusion.


"The jury may have understood the answer as directing it not to consider what the appellant did during the 'unaccounted-for time,' when there was evidence capable of supporting a reasonable inference that he continued to drink," it says.


The ruling says the judge should have reviewed the evidence the jury could consider in determining whether to infer Wilson continued to drink in the period leading up to the stabbing.


Fitch says Williams testified he began drinking heavily in the late afternoon that day, went downtown with the goal of getting drunk and continued on with that goal while he was at a restaurant for two hours.


He says the bar tab confirmed Williams drank a considerable amount of alcohol and when he left the restaurant a witness overheard him telling someone he would be going to a liquor store.


The Crown maintains the witness's statement and the evidence Williams was not displaying obvious symptoms of impairment at the scene of the offence means there is no reasonable possibility he was in an advanced state of intoxication and unable to foresee the consequences of his actions.

MORE National ARTICLES

Finance Minister Says Feds Focused On Money Laundering Fight In B.C., Globally

Finance Minister Says Feds Focused On Money Laundering Fight In B.C., Globally

VICTORIA — Finance Minister Bill Morneau says fighting money laundering in Canada and abroad is on the federal government's agenda.

 

 

Finance Minister Says Feds Focused On Money Laundering Fight In B.C., Globally

B.C. House Leaders Review Suspended Officials' Responses To Alleged Overspending

B.C. House Leaders Review Suspended Officials' Responses To Alleged Overspending

British Columbia's house leaders in the legislature say they will thoroughly consider written responses by two officials to a report that alleged they had engaged in flagrant overspending and questionable expenses.

B.C. House Leaders Review Suspended Officials' Responses To Alleged Overspending

Ottawa Objects To Giving Quebec Power To Force Immigrants To Settle In Regions

Ottawa Objects To Giving Quebec Power To Force Immigrants To Settle In Regions

The federal government, however, has the jurisdiction to grant permanent resident status, and it would have to give Quebec more powers for the legislation to have effect.

 

 

Ottawa Objects To Giving Quebec Power To Force Immigrants To Settle In Regions

Ottawa Can't Completely Block Long-Term Immigration Detainee's Lawsuit

Ottawa Can't Completely Block Long-Term Immigration Detainee's Lawsuit

A West African man who spent seven years in a maximum security prison awaiting deportation can pursue only part of his civil lawsuit against the federal government, an Ontario court has ruled.

Ottawa Can't Completely Block Long-Term Immigration Detainee's Lawsuit

RCMP Add Major Crime Detectives To Search For Missing B.C. Cowboy

RCMP Add Major Crime Detectives To Search For Missing B.C. Cowboy

KAMLOOPS, B.C. — Major crimes detectives have joined an investigation into the disappearance of a B.C. ranch employee, but RCMP say there's no evidence to suggest foul play.

RCMP Add Major Crime Detectives To Search For Missing B.C. Cowboy

B.C. Wants Federal Action After 1,500 Deaths From Illicit Overdoses Last Year

B.C. Wants Federal Action After 1,500 Deaths From Illicit Overdoses Last Year

"They are not prepared to do that at this time but we're pushing the limits within British Columbia," Judy Darcy said Thursday after the BC Coroners Service reported 1,489 people overdosed last year.

B.C. Wants Federal Action After 1,500 Deaths From Illicit Overdoses Last Year

PrevNext