Close X
Friday, May 9, 2025
ADVT 
National

Court rules B.C. law to push through Vancouver housing project is unconstitutional

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 24 Dec, 2024 10:51 AM
  • Court rules B.C. law to push through Vancouver housing project is unconstitutional

The B.C. Court of Appeal has ruled that a law passed by the provincial government to stave off opposition to a supportive housing development in the Vancouver neighbourhood of Kitsilano is unconstitutional. 

The provincial government had adopted the law at the request of the City of Vancouver in 2023 to push through a 12-storey housing development at Arbutus Street, featuring units open to low‑income residents and users of support services.

But the Arbutus development was opposed by the Kitsilano Coalition for Children & Family Safety Society, which took the city to court over its in-principle approval of a rezoning to allow the project to go ahead.

Monday's ruling says the provincial government "evidently became concerned" the litigation could delay the rezoning, so it passed the Municipal Enabling and Validating Act to facilitate the project.

The B.C. Supreme Court upheld the law in November last year, but the community group appealed, arguing the law crossed the line in bypassing the court's "supervisory role" enshrined by Constitution.

The three-judge appellate panel found the legislation "amounted to interference" with the court’s adjudicative role.

Peter Gall, the coalition's lawyers, said Monday that the ruling is a "very important rule-of-law decision."

"It affirms the constitutional principle that the legislature can't take away or usurp the right of citizens to challenge governmental action," Gall said. "That's what the legislature attempted to do here with the law it passed."

The ruling said the case wasn't about whether the housing crisis "requires action or whether the proposed development should proceed" — the "sole issue" was whether the province infringed upon the role of the court.

Gall said the coalition challenged the validity of the public hearing into the project, and did so by going to court. The provincial government "simply said that 'we deem the public hearing to be in compliance with the law,'" Gall said.

"And that's not the legislature's role. That's the court's role," Gall said. "Citizens always have the right to go to court to challenge the exercises of statutory power," he said. "That's the essence of the rule of law."

Gall said the city can't proceed with the development until it holds a valid public hearing, and the coalition still wants the opportunity to work with city council to make changes to the development between West 7th and 8th avenues to "fit it better into the community."

"They wanted to work with the city to come up with a win-win," he said. 

He said the province pressured the city to "ram" the project through, and instead of amending the law as allowed, the legislature "just prevented the court from ruling on the application of the existing law."

"The government in its haste really ignored that fundamental constitutional principle that you can't take away the right of the court to apply the existing  law," he said. 

The City of Vancouver said in a statement that it was reviewing the decision, although it was not a party to the appeal, and construction has not started. 

Housing Minister Ravi Kahlon said in a statement that the province was also reviewing the ruling. 

He said the province would "keep doing the work to make sure that more homes people need are being built."

MORE National ARTICLES

Shooting suspect on the lam in Abbotsford

Shooting suspect on the lam in Abbotsford
Police in Abbotsford say a shooting suspect is on the loose after officers were called to a Harris Road property early yesterday morning.  Police say the owner encountered an unknown man on his property and the suspect fired shots before running away after an unspecified interaction with the property owner. 

Shooting suspect on the lam in Abbotsford

Body found in Burred Inlet

Body found in Burred Inlet
Police in Port Moody say they're investigating the discovery of a dead body floating in Burrard Inlet over the weekend. Police say the body was reported on Saturday at a boat launch at Rocky Point Park. 

Body found in Burred Inlet

Edmonton police investigating after infant found dead in parking lot

Edmonton police investigating after infant found dead in parking lot
Police in Edmonton are investigating the death of an infant discovered in a shopping centre parking lot.  They say officers were called Saturday afternoon to the shopping complex in the city's south end and found the body. 

Edmonton police investigating after infant found dead in parking lot

BoC expected to lower interest rates again, with odds leaning toward larger cut

BoC expected to lower interest rates again, with odds leaning toward larger cut
Financial markets and forecasters are betting on another jumbo interest rate cut from the Bank of Canada this week. Statistics Canada's latest job report tilted expectations in favour of a larger cut. 

BoC expected to lower interest rates again, with odds leaning toward larger cut

Salvation Army says holiday donations down 50 per cent since mail strike began

Salvation Army says holiday donations down 50 per cent since mail strike began
The Salvation Army says holiday donations are down 50 per cent since the Canada Post strike began, amounting to a drop of roughly $9.3 million in seasonal giving compared to this time last year. 65 per cent of The Salvation Army's annual fundraising occurs between Nov. 1 and Dec. 31, roughly two-thirds of that by mail.

Salvation Army says holiday donations down 50 per cent since mail strike began

The Canada Post strike involving more than 55,000 has hit 25 days

The Canada Post strike involving more than 55,000 has hit 25 days
The Canada Post strike involving more than 55,000 workers has hit 25 days. In a statement Sunday, Canada Post says it is awaiting a formal response from the Canadian Union of Postal Workers to the proposal it submitted to the union Friday.

The Canada Post strike involving more than 55,000 has hit 25 days