Friday, March 29, 2024
ADVT 
National

Defence At Mother's Murder Trial Says Girls' Deaths Remain A Mystery

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 19 Feb, 2019 03:37 AM

    LAVAL, Que. — The lawyer for a Quebec mother accused of killing her two daughters said Monday that 10 years after the girls were found dead in their playroom, there is still no explanation of what happened.


    "The mystery remains whole," Pierre Poupart said during the first day of closing arguments. He told jurors there were riddles in the case they would be talking about long after the trial ended.


    His client, Adele Sorella, is accused of killing her daughters Amanda, 9, and Sabrina, 8. The cause of death was never established after the girls' bodies were found, dressed in their school uniforms, in the family home on March 30, 2009. There were no signs of violence on their bodies.


    The Crown suggested during the trial the sisters could have been killed in a hyperbaric chamber. The family bought the apparatus to treat Sabrina's juvenile arthritis. A pathologist who testified on behalf of the Crown identified the chamber as a possible cause of the deaths, suggesting the girls could have suffocated inside it.


    Poupart, however, reminded jurors that an expert in materials testified that he did not find any fibres from the girls' clothing on the mattress cover inside the hyperbaric chamber. The expert also did not find any fibres from the mattress cover on the girls' clothes.


    "This is part of the mystery," Poupart said. The lawyer warned jurors against thinking Sorella could have planned the murders and thought about possible fibre transfers: "She is not a criminal genius."


    Poupart told jurors that investigators never checked for fingerprints or signs of a break-in and failed to examine the hyperbaric chamber.


    Since the start of the investigation, there was a kind of "obsession of absolute certainty" that the person responsible for the girls' deaths was Sorella, Poupart said. The investigators' tunnel vision prevented them from looking for other clues in the case, he added.


    The Crown has maintained that only Sorella would have been able to cause the girls' deaths because no one else was in the home. But the defence has offered other theories.


    It brought up the fact Sorella's husband, Giuseppe De Vito, had installed a sophisticated alarm system in the home. De Vito, who died in prison in 2013, wasn't living with the family when his daughters were found dead. He was being sought by police as a suspect in an organized crime investigation.


    "Ask yourselves this question: Could it be interpreted as a sign of worry that her husband installed an alarm system like that?"


    The trial began in November. Poupart's closing arguments are scheduled to continue Tuesday.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Pro-Pipeline Protest Convoy Approaches Ottawa After Rolling Across Country

    Pro-Pipeline Protest Convoy Approaches Ottawa After Rolling Across Country
    The core message is we need immediate action for our pipelines to get in the ground, to get to tidewater and to the rest of Canada

    Pro-Pipeline Protest Convoy Approaches Ottawa After Rolling Across Country

    'Making This Up:' Study Says Oilsands Assessments Marred By Weak Science

    'Making This Up:' Study Says Oilsands Assessments Marred By Weak Science
    EDMONTON — Dozens of oilsands environmental impact studies are marred by inconsistent science that's rarely subjected to independent checks, says a university study.

    'Making This Up:' Study Says Oilsands Assessments Marred By Weak Science

    Carole James Says B.C. Budget Puts Priorities On NDP's Poverty, Environment Plans

    Carole James says her budget builds on the minority New Democrat government's goals of making life more affordable, improving services and ensuring a sustainable economy.

    Carole James Says B.C. Budget Puts Priorities On NDP's Poverty, Environment Plans

    Bad Weather, Lack Of Pilot Experience Cited In Quebec Crash That Killed Three

    Bad Weather, Lack Of Pilot Experience Cited In Quebec Crash That Killed Three
    The Robinson R44 Raven I helicopter left Saint-Georges-de-Beauce, Que., Feb. 1, 2018 with the pilot and 2 passengers on board headed for the province's Lanaudiere region.

    Bad Weather, Lack Of Pilot Experience Cited In Quebec Crash That Killed Three

    Mermen Calendar Targets 'Toxic Masculinity,' Raises Big Money For Charities

    This past weekend, the Newfoundland and Labrador Beard and Moustache Club gave a cheque for more than $202,000 to Violence Prevention NL.

    Mermen Calendar Targets 'Toxic Masculinity,' Raises Big Money For Charities

    'Violent' Prince George Man Arrested In Alberta After Canada-Wide Warrant Issued

    Mounties say the warrant for Tal Kalum LaRiviere was issued Feb. 2.

    'Violent' Prince George Man Arrested In Alberta After Canada-Wide Warrant Issued

    PrevNext