Wednesday, February 4, 2026
ADVT 
National

Federal Government To Take Controversy Over Face Coverings To Supreme Court

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 16 Sep, 2015 01:42 PM
    OTTAWA — The federal government will challenge a Federal Court of Appeal decision that quashed its attempts to ban face coverings at citizenship ceremonies.
     
    Immigration Minister Chris Alexander issued a terse, one-line statement Wednesday to outline the government's next step.
     
    "The government of Canada will seek leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Canada in the Ishaq case," he said. 
     
    Zunera Ishaq, a 29-year-old, devout Muslim woman who came to Ontario from Pakistan in 2008, refused to take part in a citizenship ceremony because she would have to show her face.
     
    On Tuesday, the appeal court dismissed the government's appeal of an earlier Federal Court ruling case that declared the ban on face coverings at such ceremonies was unlawful.
     
    The three-judge appeal panel ruled from the bench, saying they wanted to proceed quickly so that Ishaq could obtain citizenship in time to vote in the Oct. 19 federal election.
     
    One of Ishaq's lawyers, Marlys Edwardh, said the Immigration Department would be contacted this week so she could attend a citizenship ceremony — accompanied by her lawyers "just in case."
     
    It was not immediately clear Wednesday whether the government's stated intention to try and appeal the decision could stop Ishaq from taking the oath before the election. The government has 60 days to file an application to the top court asking it to hear the case.
     
    The ban on face coverings sparked a bitter debate in the House of Commons when it was first announced. Tuesday's ruling — and Wednesday's decision to fight it — are sure to put the issue firmly on the campaign agenda.
     
     
    Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau said it is an issue of protecting minority rights.
     
    "In any situation where a government chooses to limit or restrict individual rights or freedoms, it has to clearly explain why," he said in Calgary. "This government has not done that. It is continuing with the politics of division and even fear and that is not worthy of a country as diverse and extraordinary as Canada."
     
    The court case stems from the Conservative government's attempt to implement a ban on face coverings by ministerial order in 2011.
     
    According to documents filed in court, Immigration Department officials were leery.
     
    "My interpretation is that the minister would like this done, regardless of the legislative base and that he will use his prerogative to make policy change," one wrote to a group of colleagues in 2011.
     
    In court Tuesday, Justice Department lawyer Peter Southey surprised the judge and defence lawyers when he said the government never meant to make it mandatory for women to remove their face coverings for citizenship ceremonies.
     
    The controversial edict was a regulation that had no actual force in law, Southey told the hearing.
     
    "It indicates a desire in the strongest possible language," Southey said — an argument that appeared to come as a surprise to Justice Johanne Trudel.
     
    "I cannot see how this is not mandatory," Trudel said during the hearing.
     
    Speaking in Quebec Wednesday, Denis Lebel, Prime Minister Stephen Harper's Quebec lieutenant, suggested the government now plans to make it a mandatory by law.
     
    Lebel said that if re-elected, the Conservatives will re-introduce and adopt legislation on the oath of citizenship within 100 days.
     
    Citizenship isn't just a privilege and brings with it the responsibility to clearly identify oneself when taking the oath, he said.
     
    "When a government tables legislation, it's more than just desire," Lebel said. "We have the political belief that this is the way it has to be."

    MORE National ARTICLES

    SkyGreece Files For Protection After Halting Operations, Stranding Hundreds

    SkyGreece Files For Protection After Halting Operations, Stranding Hundreds
    MONTREAL — SkyGreece Airlines has filed for creditor protection in Canada, a week after halting operations and standing hundreds of passengers.

    SkyGreece Files For Protection After Halting Operations, Stranding Hundreds

    Police Officer's Role In Premier Paul Davis Ad Raises Questions Of Rights, Restrictions

    ST. JOHN'S, N.L. — The uproar this week over a police inspector's role in an online video endorsing the Newfoundland and Labrador premier is raising questions about rights and acceptable restrictions.

    Police Officer's Role In Premier Paul Davis Ad Raises Questions Of Rights, Restrictions

    Supreme Court Dismisses Chevron Appeal In Ecuador Environmental Damages Case

    Supreme Court Dismisses Chevron Appeal In Ecuador Environmental Damages Case
    The 7-0 ruling allows the case to proceed in Canada, but it makes no finding on the merits of the long-running legal saga that has played out in courtrooms across the Western Hemisphere.

    Supreme Court Dismisses Chevron Appeal In Ecuador Environmental Damages Case

    Photo Project With The New Yorker Magazine Features Residential School Survivors

    Photo Project With The New Yorker Magazine Features Residential School Survivors
    International photojournalist Daniella Zalcman has partnered with The New Yorker magazine to show her project on Canada's residential school survivors.

    Photo Project With The New Yorker Magazine Features Residential School Survivors

    Manitoba Government Adds Support Money For Syrian Refugees

    Premier Greg Selinger says an extra $40,000 is being given to settlement service providers in the province, so that they can accommodate hundreds more refugees in the coming months.

    Manitoba Government Adds Support Money For Syrian Refugees

    First Byelection Since NDP Victory In Alberta Goes To Wildrose Party

    First Byelection Since NDP Victory In Alberta Goes To Wildrose Party
    Wildrose Leader Brian Jean, a former Conservative MP under Harper, told party supporters to take a short breather before getting back to the campaign grind.

    First Byelection Since NDP Victory In Alberta Goes To Wildrose Party