Sunday, June 7, 2026
ADVT 
National

Five things to know about the Supreme Court's assisted dying ruling

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 06 Feb, 2015 02:11 PM

    OTTAWA — The Supreme Court of Canada has unanimously overturned its own 1993 decision and struck down a ban on providing a doctor-assisted death to mentally competent but suffering and "irremediable" patients. Here are five things to know about the decision.

    ---

    In 1993, in the Sue Rodriguez case, the court ruled 5-4 that the ban on assisted suicide was a violation of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, but was reasonable under Sec. 1 of the charter. The two cases, while similar on their face, actually pivoted on different points of constitutional law.

    ---

    In the latest case, a British Columbia judge said she was justified in revisiting Rodriguez and the Supreme Court agreed. "Trial courts may reconsider settled rulings of higher courts in two situations: (1) where a new legal issue is raised; and (2) where there is a change in the circumstances or evidence that fundamentally shifts the parameters of the debate. Here, both conditions were met."

    ---

    The high court pointed out that in 1993, assisted suicide was a rarity around the world, with some jurisdictions turning a blind eye to the practice while officially outlawing it. "By 2010, however, eight jurisdictions permitted some form of assisted dying: the Netherlands, Belgium, Luxembourg, Switzerland, Oregon, Washington, Montana and Colombia."

    ---

    In ruling that the blanket prohibition on assisted suicide is unconstitutional, the justices suspended the decision for a year to allow the federal government to draft legislation that recognizes the right of plainly consenting adults who are enduring intolerable suffering — physical or mental — to seek medical help to end their lives.

    ---

    The decision will be a political bomb in a Parliament already counting down to an October election. Tory MP Steven Fletcher, a quadriplegic who has two private bills on assisted dying before the Commons, says the government could easily take the issue off the election radar by acting before Parliament rises in June. Justice Minister Peter MacKay says only that the government will take its time.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    RCAF to test rapid rescue response time as new planes remain in limbo

    RCAF to test rapid rescue response time as new planes remain in limbo
    OTTAWA — The air force is planning to test an expanded, more flexible response time for search and rescue along the East Coast in the coming year, even as long-delayed plans for new aircraft remain in a holding pattern.

    RCAF to test rapid rescue response time as new planes remain in limbo

    Trial Date To Be Set For Retired B.C. Teacher Facing Child Pornography Charge

    Trial Date To Be Set For Retired B.C. Teacher Facing Child Pornography Charge
    KAMLOOPS, B.C. — A retired teacher facing a child-pornography charge will return to B.C. Supreme Court in two weeks to set a trial date.

    Trial Date To Be Set For Retired B.C. Teacher Facing Child Pornography Charge

    Snowfall In B.C.'s Central Okanagan Breaks Records Dating From 1899

    Snowfall In B.C.'s Central Okanagan Breaks Records Dating From 1899
    KELOWNA, B.C. — Environment Canada says a recent snowfall in B.C.'s Central Okanagan region broke records dating as far back as 1899.

    Snowfall In B.C.'s Central Okanagan Breaks Records Dating From 1899

    Vulnerable Witnesses To Get Support From Crown Years After Pickton Dodged Trial

    Vulnerable Witnesses To Get Support From Crown Years After Pickton Dodged Trial
    VANCOUVER — The failure of Crown prosecutors to press a drug-addicted woman nearly murdered by Robert Pickton to testify against the serial killer has inspired new policy to support vulnerable witnesses.

    Vulnerable Witnesses To Get Support From Crown Years After Pickton Dodged Trial

    Quebec union boss 'Rambo' Gauthier to appeal intimidation conviction

    Quebec union boss 'Rambo' Gauthier to appeal intimidation conviction
    MONTREAL — A high-ranking Quebec union boss who was found guilty of intimidating a contractor is appealing his conviction.

    Quebec union boss 'Rambo' Gauthier to appeal intimidation conviction

    Crews Find No Sign Of Missing Vancouver Man On Nearby North Shore Mountains

    Crews Find No Sign Of Missing Vancouver Man On Nearby North Shore Mountains
    VANCOUVER — Search crews have found no signs of 21-year old Liang Jin of Vancouver who is believed to have gone for a hike on the North Shore Mountains last week.

    Crews Find No Sign Of Missing Vancouver Man On Nearby North Shore Mountains