Saturday, June 28, 2025
ADVT 
National

Judge in hockey players' trial rules ex-teammate's texts not currently admissible

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 23 May, 2025 10:40 AM
  • Judge in hockey players' trial rules ex-teammate's texts not currently admissible

Texts sent by a former member of Canada's world junior hockey team cannot currently be admitted at the sexual assault trial of five of his ex-teammates, an Ontario judge ruled Friday, prompting prosecutors to seek a different route to introduce the messages as evidence.

Brett Howden faced questions Thursday in a voir dire — essentially a trial within a trial — over a text conversation he had with another then-teammate, Taylor Raddysh, on June 26, 2018.

In the exchange, Howden describes some parts of the June 19, 2018 encounter at the heart of the trial, including a moment when he says one of the accused, Dillon Dube, slapped the complainant on the buttocks.

"Dude, I'm so happy I left when all the s--t went down haha," the message reads. "When I was leaving, Duber (Dube) was smacking this girl's a-- so hard, like it looked like it hurt so bad."

Dube, Michael McLeod, Alex Formenton, Carter Hart and Callan Foote have pleaded not guilty to sexual assault. McLeod has also pleaded not guilty to an additional charge of being a party to the offence of sexual assault.

The Crown alleges McLeod, Hart and Dube obtained oral sex from the woman without her consent, and Dube slapped her buttocks while she was engaged in a sexual act with someone else.

Foote is accused of doing the splits over her face and grazing his genitals on it without her consent. Formenton is alleged to have had vaginal sex with the complainant without her consent inside the bathroom.

The Crown sought to introduce the messages related to the slap as a "past recollection recorded" — a prior statement captured in some form — due to Howden's lack of memory on certain details of the events, even after reviewing his previous statements.

Part of the test to admit a recorded recollection as evidence is establishing whether the witness can vouch for its truthfulness, and Ontario Superior Court Justice Maria Carroccia said Howden didn't meet that threshold.

"Although Mr. Howden testified that he wasn't trying to lie when he sent that message, he did not testify that that message was true," the judge said.

"He was uncertain and said different things in examination in chief and cross-examination about that message, at times agreeing that he cannot say that it was accurate, and at other times saying he had no reason to lie."

The Crown is now seeking to have the texts admitted through what it called the last avenue available: the principled exception to hearsay, a mechanism through which hearsay evidence can be admitted if it is deemed necessary and reliable. 

Defence lawyers for the players are opposing the application.

Carroccia is expected to rule on the application Monday.

Picture Courtesy; THE CANADIAN PRESS/Nicole Osborne

MORE National ARTICLES

G7 finance ministers to wrap up summit in Banff

G7 finance ministers to wrap up summit in Banff
Here is a roundup of stories from The Canadian Press designed to bring you up to speed...

G7 finance ministers to wrap up summit in Banff

B.C. seen as 'final frontier' for federal NDP as leadership question looms

B.C. seen as 'final frontier' for federal NDP as leadership question looms
Kelowna resident and former federal NDP candidate Cade Desjarlais sees the party in "disarray." 

B.C. seen as 'final frontier' for federal NDP as leadership question looms

Prime Minister Mark Carney sworn in as MP for Ottawa riding of Nepean

Prime Minister Mark Carney sworn in as MP for Ottawa riding of Nepean
Prime Minister Mark Carney was officially sworn in as a member of Parliament Thursday, and will take his seat in the House of Commons for the first time on May 26.

Prime Minister Mark Carney sworn in as MP for Ottawa riding of Nepean

Union says Canada Post offers 'fall short' as strike deadline nears

Union says Canada Post offers 'fall short' as strike deadline nears
The union representing about 55,000 Canada Post employees said the latest offers from the postal service "fall short" with hours to go until a looming strike deadline.

Union says Canada Post offers 'fall short' as strike deadline nears

Vancouver police say Downtown Eastside crime drops after adoption of task force

Vancouver police say Downtown Eastside crime drops after adoption of task force
Police in Vancouver have released new data they say depicts the success of a task force launched three months ago to curb crime in the city's Downtown Eastside neighbourhood.

Vancouver police say Downtown Eastside crime drops after adoption of task force

Carney 'devastated and appalled' by killing of 2 Israeli embassy staff in Washington

Carney 'devastated and appalled' by killing of 2 Israeli embassy staff in Washington
Prime Minister Mark Carney said he is "devastated and appalled" by the killing of two Israeli embassy staff in Washington on Wednesday.

Carney 'devastated and appalled' by killing of 2 Israeli embassy staff in Washington