Close X
Tuesday, May 13, 2025
ADVT 
National

Jurors at Luka Rocco Magnotta trial ask question on Day 2 of deliberations

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 17 Dec, 2014 10:47 AM

    MONTREAL — Jurors at Luka Rocco Magnotta's murder trial have emerged for the first time since they began deliberating — not with a verdict but with a legal question for the judge.

    The jury is asking whether a personality disorder is considered a disease of the mind, according to the law.

    Deliberations have been suspended while the court decides how to answer the question, one that suggests the jury is still considering the not criminally responsible defence presented by Magnotta.

    The accused is charged with first-degree murder and four other charges in the slaying and dismemberment of Chinese engineering student Jun Lin in May 2012.

    The defence has argued that Magnotta is schizophrenia and was off medication, leaving him psychotic during and after the slaying.

    Defence experts testified that while he understood what he was doing, Magnotta could not tell right from wrong.

    The Crown countered the crimes were planned and deliberate and that the steps Magnotta took to hide his tracks and flee authorities were not consistent with someone suffering from a mental disorder.

    Prosecutor Louis Bouthillier said Magnotta's schizophrenia was a misdiagnosis and that his medical problems and behaviour are likely the result of personality disorders.

    The eight women and four men officially began their work Tuesday and completed the day without reaching verdicts.

    They must deliver five unanimous verdicts in the case.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Veterans Affairs hiring amid controversy over service delays, lapsed funding

    Veterans Affairs hiring amid controversy over service delays, lapsed funding
    OTTAWA — The Harper government is looking to hire staff at Veterans Affairs.

    Veterans Affairs hiring amid controversy over service delays, lapsed funding

    Family of slain officer feeling 'pain, anger and despair' on eve of verdict

    Family of slain officer feeling 'pain, anger and despair' on eve of verdict
    CALGARY — Family members of a slain Alberta peace officer say they are feeling pain, anger and despair on the eve of a verdict in the trial of a man accused of killing him.

    Family of slain officer feeling 'pain, anger and despair' on eve of verdict

    Axworthy welcomes Kerry musing on U.S. joining Ottawa landmines treaty

    Axworthy welcomes Kerry musing on U.S. joining Ottawa landmines treaty
    OTTAWA — Former Liberal foreign minister Lloyd Axworthy says he's hopeful the United States will join the international treaty to ban landmines, which the Americans have snubbed since it was signed in Ottawa 17 years ago.

    Axworthy welcomes Kerry musing on U.S. joining Ottawa landmines treaty

    Critics question Harper's rationale for stalled oil and gas regs to curb GHGs

    Critics question Harper's rationale for stalled oil and gas regs to curb GHGs
    OTTAWA — Opposition critics and energy experts are questioning Prime Minister Stephen Harper's contention that Canada can't move to curb greenhouse gas emissions from the oil and gas sector without American alignment.

    Critics question Harper's rationale for stalled oil and gas regs to curb GHGs

    Supreme Court to rule on privacy rights for cellphone users arrested by police

    Supreme Court to rule on privacy rights for cellphone users arrested by police
    OTTAWA — The Supreme Court of Canada delivers a precedent-setting ruling Thursday that's expected to dictate how much warrantless access police can have to a person's cellphone.

    Supreme Court to rule on privacy rights for cellphone users arrested by police

    Conservative MP's bill would let caucuses decide which colleagues are in or out

    Conservative MP's bill would let caucuses decide which colleagues are in or out
    OTTAWA — A Conservative MP's bill rapidly making its way through the House of Commons could restrict leaders in the future from unilaterally suspending MPs — a point very relevant on Parliament Hill this year.

    Conservative MP's bill would let caucuses decide which colleagues are in or out