Sunday, May 19, 2024
ADVT 
National

Lawyer denies child pornography claim in Todd case

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 03 Aug, 2022 03:51 PM
  • Lawyer denies child pornography claim in Todd case

NEW WESTMINSTER, B.C. - Sharing a link is "not child pornography," says a defence lawyer for a Dutch man accused of harassment and extortion of British Columbia teenager Amanda Todd.

Joseph Saulnier told the jury in Aydin Coban's B.C. Supreme Court trial Wednesday there was evidence that a video titled "AmandaTodd.wmv" was played on a device seized from his client's home, but it was not stored as a data file.

Coban has pleaded not guilty to extortion, harassment, communication with a young person to commit a sexual offence and possessing child pornography in relation to the Port Coquitlam, B.C., teen.

Earlier in the trial, Crown attorney Marcel Daigle cited testimony from a Dutch officer who said a deleted video file called "AmandaTodd.wmv'' had been played on one of the devices in December 2010, corresponding with a time when Todd was being actively harassed.

But Saulnier said the evidence "does not support the existence of a data file of child pornography on Amanda Todd."

The video was sent out as a link but there was nothing to show it was stored as data on the seized devices, Saulnier told the jury on the second day of his closing argument.

"Can you look at this and be satisfied beyond a reasonable doubt of the possession of a data file of child pornography? No," he said.

Crown attorney Louise Kenworthy had wrapped up her closing arguments Tuesday saying there was a "treasure trove of information" linking Coban to the harassment and extortion of Todd.

When the trial began about two months ago, the Crown told the jury Todd had been the victim of a persistent campaign of online "sextortion'' over three years before her death at age 15 in October 2012.

Saulnier focused on the Crown's claim that it was the same person, Coban, who operated various accounts involved in Todd's harassment.

“I say Crown established there are connections between these accounts. It's not a coincidence. I agree it’s not a coincidence," he said. "Doesn’t mean it’s the same person.”

He pointed to differences in the way capital letters, grammar, apostrophes and abbreviations were used by the various accounts, then drew a contrast with the way Todd wrote throughout the exchanges.

"So Amanda Todd again, she's writing in all lowercase, not using capitals, that's consistent. She writes the same way," he said.

The defence lawyer also told the jury that various Facebook accounts that targeted Todd had operated on internet browsers that were not found on the seized devices.

“This is a significant hole in Crown’s theory,” he said.

“This is actually evidence of people accessing these Facebook accounts from other devices, from other computers, evidence of other people using these Facebook accounts.”

There were no cookies from Facebook found on the seized devices, Saulnier said Wednesday, referring to pieces of data that websites use to track users and their preferences.

"Even if you manually or automatically delete your cookies … for privacy — that (deleted) cookie — it goes to deleted space," he said.

"Finding a fragment doesn't mean that whoever had that device is the author of the message."

Saulnier had said Tuesday that what he called fragments of computer data cited by the Crown could not link Coban to the extortion and harassment of Todd.

MORE National ARTICLES

Hot but no emergency say B.C. officials

Hot but no emergency say B.C. officials
Environment Canada is maintaining heat warnings for most of B.C. and says 10 daily maximum temperature records were broken Wednesday as the province recorded the top dozen highest temperatures in Canada. At 42 C, Lytton was the hottest in the province and the country as the weather office says the village broke its previous record for the day of 40 C, set in 1939.

Hot but no emergency say B.C. officials

Prevent spread of monkeypox with safe sex: Tam

Prevent spread of monkeypox with safe sex: Tam
The World Health Organization declared the virus a public health emergency of international concern over the weekend. Tam, the chief public health officer, said there are 745 confirmed cases of the monkeypox reported in Canada and 99 per cent of those affected are men with a median age of 36.

Prevent spread of monkeypox with safe sex: Tam

Over $8 million in drugs and more than $170K in cash seized over gang activity: VPD

Over $8 million in drugs and more than $170K in cash seized over gang activity: VPD
Detectives in the VPD’s Organized Crime Section initiated Project Tint in May 2022 to target drug sales and distributions within a high-level organized crime group linked to the Lower Mainland gang conflict.

Over $8 million in drugs and more than $170K in cash seized over gang activity: VPD

B.C. teen pushed back against extortionist: Crown

B.C. teen pushed back against extortionist: Crown
Kristen LeNoble says Todd also made a post on Facebook, asking people she was connected with to support her, and not judge her, as she feared her harasser was about to distribute a link depicting her in a sexual manner.

B.C. teen pushed back against extortionist: Crown

Hockey Canada paid $7.6M in settlements

Hockey Canada paid $7.6M in settlements
The hockey governing body has been under fire since it was revealed the money in its multimillion-dollar National Equity Fund — which had been reserved for uninsured payments including sexual assault and sexual abuse claims — comes from player fees.

Hockey Canada paid $7.6M in settlements

Canadian Blood Services criticized over masks move

Canadian Blood Services criticized over masks move
The agency says people are still welcome to wear masks if they want, but mandatory masking and physical distancing were suspended as of Monday after consultation with medical and epidemiology experts.  

Canadian Blood Services criticized over masks move