TORONTO — The Tenors member Remigio Pereira officially apologized Friday for altering the lyrics to O Canada prior to this week's Major League Baseball all-star game.
While singing a solo verse of the anthem, he changed the lyrics "With glowing hearts we see thee rise, the True North strong and free," to "We're all brothers and sisters, all lives matter to the great."
He also held up a sign bearing the message "all lives matter" on one side and "united we stand" on the other, while standing alongside his fellow Tenors on the field.
In a video posted on his Facebook page, an emotional Pereira said he knows O Canada is revered and he wasn't intending to disrespect the anthem, the people of Canada, or "the people who have fallen for this country to be free."
Pereira also said those who were offended by his "all lives matter" message should know that he's not a racist.
"I have a biracial daughter, grew up in a multicultural environment where my best friend was black. I grew up with friends from Laos, from Asia — people from all over the world," he said.
"My intention was to bring unity and peace through loving one another. That has always been my message.
He also apologized directly to members of the Black Lives Matter movement.
"I stand with you for your voice. It deserves to be heard. You have been persecuted for many, many centuries, and I believe that nobody has a right above anyone else, no matter race or creed."
Social media lit up with widespread derision of Pereira's unanticipated move, while the other three Tenor members distanced themselves from him, saying in a statement that he acted as a "lone wolf."
Pereira said he "lost everything" from his actions — including the respect of his band. He said he hasn't spoken with fellow Tenors Victor Micallef, Clifton Murray and Fraser Walters in person since the incident.
"We've always sung about leading with our hearts and being under one sky, which are some of the anthems that we write expressing our love for humanity, for all people, and for sharing love with one another. That has always been my message and the message of the band.
"I'd like to apologize to Victor, Fraser and Clifton. I haven't spoken to them yet in person, but I want you to know that I am sorry for putting you in that situation."
CROWD DEMANDS MORE GOVERNMENT ACTION ON RACISM AT ONTARIO MEETING; WYNNE CHIDES 'LONE WOLF' TENOR
TORONTO — The first public meeting of the Ontario government's new anti-racism directorate drew a packed and vocal crowd Thursday as Premier Kathleen Wynne said governments need to do more to battle discrimination.
Wynne said she believes governments haven't gone far enough to create a more equitable society.
"I understand that government institutions have not lived up to that," she said. "Part of doing my job is acknowledging that we haven't done enough."
Audience members lined up to voice their opinions during the open consultation period, some waiting past the planned 9 p.m. end time to speak. The crowd crammed into overflow spaces well beyond the 300-person capacity of the meeting room.
The room broke out into cheers of "black lives matter" several times throughout the night as people spoke, with some speakers leading chants and singing songs.
Many were critical of government officials, saying that not enough concrete action has been taken to deal with racism despite years of activism.
Akua Benjamin was the first speaker at the microphone. She credited the activist group Black Lives Matter Toronto for calling for the public meeting and bringing people together.
"There hasn't been a time in the last 50 years when we have not marched on the streets of Toronto calling out to put an end to racism," she said.
"And so here we are again. ... Here we are many years later doing the same thing, calling attention to the issue of racism. It really is a shame."
Wynne and Michael Coteau, the province's minister of children and youth services, opened the event with remarks to the crowd.
Toronto Mayor John Tory was also present at the meeting but unlike Wynne and Coteau, he did not have a formal slot to address the crowd.
However, he did speak after a woman asked him when he planned to have his own anti-racism community meeting.
Tory said he had agreed to two series of meetings in addition to the anti-racism directorate meetings, including consultations on a report on police reform in August.
Before the meeting, Wynne said that when people say "all lives matter" in response to the Black Lives Matter movement, it reminds her of people saying: "Why don't straight people have a parade?"
Wynne, who is openly gay, also responded to questions about a member of The Tenors changing the national anthem's lyrics at the Major League Baseball all-star game earlier this week to contain the controversial phrase "all lives matter."
"I think what is heard by people who heard him sing that is that, 'You don't understand what we're saying. What we're saying is that there's a particular issue,'" she said.
"It's like when people have said to me in the past, 'Well, straight people don't have a parade. Why don't straight people have a parade? Everybody should be proud of who they are.' Well, yeah, that's true, but straight people experience life differently than gay, lesbian, bi, transgender (and) two-spirited people. So I think that there's a lot of misunderstanding that happens when we get into the use of language in this way."
Wynne added it appears that tenor Remigio Pereira, who also held up a sign bearing the message, "made a big, big mistake in terms of his career."
Also ahead of the anti-racism meeting, Wynne said Pride Toronto and Black Lives Matter Toronto will have to discuss their issues without her input.
Black Lives Matter temporarily halted the Pride earlier this month to make a series of demands that included more funding and better representation for racialized communities during Pride events. It also called for a ban on police floats in future parades.
Wynne said people can debate specific tactics, but the group is raising issues of systemic racism "that have to be taken seriously."
"People have a right to peaceful protest and we as a government have a responsibility, and I would suggest we as a society have a responsibility, to tackle the challenges of systemic discrimination as we see them."
Wynne stepped outside the Ontario legislature in April to speak to a crowd of Black Lives Matter protesters and told them she was willing to set up a formal meeting. That has not yet happened, but Wynne said Thursday that it would take place "later in the fall, perhaps."
