Saturday, June 1, 2024
ADVT 
National

Mother On Hook For Thousands Of Dollars After Son Crashes Rented Minivan

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 11 Sep, 2019 05:34 PM

    TORONTO - A woman who rented a minivan is on the hook for thousands of dollars after her son, who had a suspended licence, got behind the wheel and crashed, an Ontario judge has ruled.

     

    The Superior Court ruled that Tricia Richards must cover the costs of replacing the vehicle — said to be a write-off — even though she had bought optional insurance coverage at the time of rental.

     

    In his decision, Justice Russell Raikes said it was clear that Enterprise Rent-A-Car had not given her son Christopher permission to drive, and the damage waiver she had purchased did not apply.

     

    "The agreement expressly says that the waiver is invalidated if someone other than the renter or additional authorized driver operated the vehicle without the owner's written consent," Raikes wrote in his ruling. "Once Christopher got behind the wheel of the van and put it in gear, the waiver was invalidated. That is so whether he had Ms. Richards' permission or not."

     

    Richards had rented the 2017 Dodge Caravan at the Calgary international airport in April 2017 with a view to returning it in Winnipeg. She was the only driver listed on the rental contract. She also bought the optional collision damage waiver, which covers damage for which a renter would have to pay.

     

    Days later, with her son at the wheel, the vehicle left the highway and rolled. Enterprise sought $35,311 in replacement costs from her after deciding it would cost more than $82,000 to repair the vehicle.

     

    Richards disputed the claim. She argued she had been driving but that, after stopping for gas, she returned to the minivan and found her son behind the wheel. She said she got into the passenger seat and tried to dissuade him from driving, but was tired and gave up when he insisted.

     

    "I had absolutely no control of the situation and was wary that my safety was involved if I did anything further to frustrate him," she said in submissions.

     

    She also said she had no idea his licence had been suspended, which led to charges against him after the crash.

     

    Raikes, however, said it was irrelevant whether or not Richards had given her son permission to drive. What was clear, he said, is that the rental company had not done so. Raikes sided with the plaintiff.

     

    The judge did refuse to order Richards to pay the $35,311 Enterprise was demanding. The rental company, he said, had provided no solid evidence to substantiate the amount claimed beyond providing one repair estimate and one estimate of the value of the minivan.

     

    "The information being provided is opinion evidence," Raikes said. "There is no meaningful way to cross-examine and challenge the authors."

     

    How much Richards should pay Enterprise should be decided at a trial by another judge, who will also rule on how much she owes to cover the company's legal costs, Raikes said.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Joshua Boyle's Lawyers Want Charge Of Misleading Police Thrown Out

    Lawyers for former Afghanistan hostage Joshua Boyle want a judge to toss out a charge that he misled police — one of several criminal counts he faces in Ontario court.

    Joshua Boyle's Lawyers Want Charge Of Misleading Police Thrown Out

    Quebec Woman Waiting For News Of Her Parents Trapped In Bahamas During Hurricane

    MONTREAL - A Montreal-area woman says she's desperately waiting for news of her parents, who were trapped in the northern Bahamas when Hurricane Dorian battered the region as a massive Category 5 storm.    

    Quebec Woman Waiting For News Of Her Parents Trapped In Bahamas During Hurricane

    33-Year-Old Man Presumed Drowned Following Shuswap Lake Speedboat Incident

    33-Year-Old Man Presumed Drowned Following Shuswap Lake Speedboat Incident
    RCMP in British Columbia are searching for a man, presumed drowned, following a boating incident on Shuswap Lake east of Kamloops.

    33-Year-Old Man Presumed Drowned Following Shuswap Lake Speedboat Incident

    New Brunswick Police Consider Charges After Three Die In Car Crash

    New Brunswick Police Consider Charges After Three Die In Car Crash
    Police in New Brunswick say they're considering charges against a 28-year-old student after the car he was driving crashed, resulting in the deaths of three young men in the back seat.

    New Brunswick Police Consider Charges After Three Die In Car Crash

    Federal NDP Choose 'In It For You' As Slogan

    The federal New Democrats have settled on "In it for You" as their English slogan for the upcoming federal election campaign.

    Federal NDP Choose 'In It For You' As Slogan

    Barenaked Ladies Musician Awarded $60,000 In Legal Battle Over Painting

    A Toronto gallery must now pay tens of thousands of dollars to a Canadian musician who alleged he was sold a fake painting purported to be by the renowned Indigenous artist Norval Morrisseau.

    Barenaked Ladies Musician Awarded $60,000 In Legal Battle Over Painting