Saturday, December 20, 2025
ADVT 
National

Muclair Says Scottish Referendum Result Must Be Respected But Won't Take Sides

The Canadian Press , 10 Sep, 2014 11:00 PM
  • Muclair Says Scottish Referendum Result Must Be Respected But Won't Take Sides
Tom Mulcair is refusing to take sides in the nailbiter referendum on Scottish independence.
 
But however it turns out, the NDP leader says the result will have to be respected.
 
"I think that it couldn't be clearer that international law has been very firmly respected here, there's been clear negotiations on everything from the question to the information that had to be put forward and the final decision is simply with the Scottish people," Mulcair said Wednesday.
 
Polls suggest the Sept. 18 referendum is going down to the wire with the Yes and No camps in a dead heat — reminiscent of the 1995 referendum on Quebec independence which came within a whisker of breaking up Canada.
 
Prime Minister Stephen Harper waded into the Scottish referendum debate last week while in London, telling a business audience it was not in the "greater global interest" for the United Kingdom to break up. And he drew a direct link to the separatist movement in Quebec.
 
"What would the division of a country like Canada, or the division of a country like the United Kingdom, do to advance solutions to any of these issues?" Harper asked, pointing to global challenges such as terrorism and climate change.
 
Alex Salmond, the Scottish First Minister, this week derided Harper's intervention as a sign of desperation on the part of U.K. Prime Minister David Cameron and the No camp.
 
Mulcair said he's "going to avoid doing the same" as Harper.
 
"I think that in instances like this, you're better off leaving people in another country to make their own decisions. I think that the British have all the tools at their disposal to make all the interventions that they want in the current referendum process and Mr. Salmond seems more than capable of responding as things roll out."
 
That said, Mulcair, who fought on the No side in Quebec's two referendums, volunteered that "senior representatives" of the U.K.'s Scotland office asked to meet with him last April when he was in London.
 
"They knew my experience in the two Quebec referenda and they wanted to talk about messaging," he said.
 
Mulcair acknowledged that some might try to use a Yes vote in Scotland to reignite the currently moribund separatist movement in Quebec. But he cautioned against drawing parallels with independence votes in other countries.
 
He noted that the Spanish region of Catalonia is facing its own independence referendum in November but said that it's "going to be a completely different kettle of fish." Among other things, the Spanish courts have ruled the referendum process unconstitutional.
 
 
Mulcair is evidently unfazed by the spectre that the Scots could vote to secede by a razor thin margin. Indeed, he noted that the NDP has proposed the "unity act" to deal with such a scenario recurring in Canada.
 
The unity act spells out that a bare majority of 50 per cent plus one vote would be sufficient to trigger negotiations on Quebec's secession, provided that the referendum question was clear and there were no "determinative irregularities" in the vote.
 
"The NDP has taken the time to put something solid and clear on the table ... We're very comfortable with the position that has the support of all elements of our caucus, wherever they're from in Canada," Mulcair said.
 
The NDP has designed its unity act to replace the Clarity Act, introduced by Jean Chretien's Liberal government after the near-death experience in 1995.
 
The Clarity Act specifies that the federal government will not negotiate secession unless a clear majority votes Yes on a clear referendum question. It does not specify what constitutes a clear majority, allowing parliamentarians to take into account voter turnout, voting irregularities and other factors before concluding whether the result is sufficiently unambiguous to warrant divorce talks.
 
Mulcair offered his comments on the Scottish referendum outside an NDP caucus retreat to plot strategy for what New Democrats believe will be a year of non-stop campaigning ahead of the next scheduled federal election in October 2015.
 
The party unveiled an election slogan aimed at reasserting its claim to be the real alternative to Harper's Conservative government: "Change that's ready."
 
The slogan is meant to contrast Mulcair's experience and his party's policy depth with what New Democrats see as the empty promises of neophyte Liberal Leader Justin Trudeau.
 
And it's consistent with the party's decision to begin unveiling key planks of its election platform a full year before the actual campaign begins.
 
"People are tired of talking points, they're fed up with partisan attacks. They don't want empty phrases and platitudes, they want things that are real," Mulcair said.
 
Among other things, the party intends to nail down platform planks on funding health care, creating a national child care program and reinstating a federal minimum wage.
 
The risky strategy could give rival parties a chance to trash NDP proposals or steal the best ones. But New Democrats are hoping it will remind Canadians that the NDP is the real contender for power, not the Liberals, who've been leading in opinion polls since Trudeau took the helm 18 months ago.
 
In a brief speech to his 96 MPs, Mulcair asserted that Canadians are for the first time looking at the NDP as a government in waiting.
 
Since vaulting past the Liberals to become the official Opposition in 2011, Mulcair said New Democrats have been "showing Canadians that we are ready to take on Stephen Harper's Conservatives and they now know this team does have the leadership and the experience to form government tomorrow morning."
 
Nevertheless, some MPs betrayed frustration with the constant questions about why the NDP is trailing in third place in the polls if, as they maintain, Trudeau is such an empty vessel.
 
Charlie Angus, veteran NDP MP from northern Ontario, chose to respond to the questions  with sarcasm, saying he's "literally terrified" to find that voters in his riding have tattooed Trudeau's name on their necks.
 
"In Kirkland Lake, you see a man like me running in fear for his life," he joked.

MORE National ARTICLES

Sobbing Kelowna Driver Expresses Remorse For High Speed Crash That Killed Mother Of Two

Sobbing Kelowna Driver Expresses Remorse For High Speed Crash That Killed Mother Of Two
KELOWNA, B.C. - A Kelowna, B.C., man has been sentenced to 15 months in jail, one year probation and banned from driving for two years for causing a fatal crash in neighbouring West Kelowna.

Sobbing Kelowna Driver Expresses Remorse For High Speed Crash That Killed Mother Of Two

Lost In Manitoba Wilderness For 3 Days, Man Lived On All-Dressed Chips, Rainwater

Lost In Manitoba Wilderness For 3 Days, Man Lived On All-Dressed Chips, Rainwater
Christopher Cloutier was camping with friends in Nopiming Provincial Park in southeastern Manitoba when they got separated.

Lost In Manitoba Wilderness For 3 Days, Man Lived On All-Dressed Chips, Rainwater

B.C. Teachers And Employer Add Bargaining Committees To Meeting With Mediator

B.C. Teachers And Employer Add Bargaining Committees To Meeting With Mediator
VANCOUVER - Teachers and the B.C. government's negotiator are expected to bring their bargaining committees to discussions with veteran mediator Vince Ready today.

B.C. Teachers And Employer Add Bargaining Committees To Meeting With Mediator

B.C. Tour Bus Crash: RCMP Say They Have Footage; Speed Not Factor

B.C. Tour Bus Crash: RCMP Say They Have Footage; Speed Not Factor
MERRITT, B.C. - The Mounties say a dashboard camera from a tractor-trailer captured a tour bus rollover that injured dozens of people on a B.C. highway and it appears speed is not a factor.

B.C. Tour Bus Crash: RCMP Say They Have Footage; Speed Not Factor

Diner en Blanc Vancouver 2014

Diner en Blanc Vancouver 2014
The normally green David Lam Park in Vancouver’s Yaletown district turned into a sea of white for the third annual Vancouver Dîner en Blanc outdoor dining phenomenon last week. 

Diner en Blanc Vancouver 2014

Remains found in B.C. matched to 20-year-old Ontario man missing since 2003

Remains found in B.C. matched to 20-year-old Ontario man missing since 2003
NORTH VANCOUVER, B.C. - Human remains found in the mountains near North Vancouver have been identified as those of a 20-year-old Ontario man who went missing more than a decade ago while visiting his grandmother in British Columbia.

Remains found in B.C. matched to 20-year-old Ontario man missing since 2003