Saturday, December 20, 2025
ADVT 
National

New Democrat MP quits party, complains that Mulcair is too pro-Israel

Darpan News Desk Darpan, 20 Aug, 2014 03:05 PM
    OTTAWA - A New Democrat MP has quit the caucus over what she felt was an excessively pro-Israel stance on the current conflict in Gaza and demeaning party demands to toe the line.
     
    Sana Hassainia, who represents the Montreal-area riding of Vercheres-Les Patriotes, was specifically critical of NDP Leader Tom Mulcair in a blog post that appeared online Wednesday.
     
    Hassainia alleged that she was "punished" for supporting Mulcair rival Brian Topp for the party leadership, including losing her position on the Commons committee on the status of women. She also said she was forced to stay quiet over her views on the Middle East and accept a position that didn't align with her values.
     
    "For me, a party leader should be loved like (former leader) Jack Layton and not feared," wrote Hassainia, who is originally from Tunisia.
     
    "Today, I have the courage to make a significant gesture, to take a weight off my shoulders and stand by my convictions."
     
    However, NDP sources said Hassainia has never before voiced concern over Mulcair's position on Israel and accused her of simply looking for an excuse to cover the fact that she rarely shows up for work.
     
    Mulcair, speaking at a news conference in Toronto, said the party has never made a secret of its position on the Middle East.
     
    "The NDP has a long-standing position in favour of the two state solution in the Middle East — a safe, secure state within negotiated borders for Israelis and a safe, secure state within negotiated borders for Palestinians," he said.
     
    "Sana in her note made it clear she doesn't agree with that. That's been our position for many years, it was Jack's position, it's mine, and so she's decided that she doesn't want to sit with us. That's her choice."
     
    So far this year, Hassainia has the worst voting record of all MPs, showing up for only 8.7 per cent of votes in the House of Commons.
     
    Since winning election in 2011 as part of the so-called "orange wave" that swept Quebec, the 39-year-old has given birth to two children.
     
    A source close to Mulcair said the party bent over backwards trying to accommodate Hassainia's need to be with her young children, even letting her use the leader's office to breastfeed. But still the party's whip, Nycole Turmel, was frustrated in her efforts to get Hassainia to show up for votes and perform other parliamentary duties.
     
    Hassainia had been preparing to announce next week that she would not seek re-election.
     
    In a draft of that announcement, prepared last month and obtained by The Canadian Press, Hassainia cites the need to spend more time with her young family as the sole reason for her decision. And she says she intends to remain an active and proud member of the NDP.
     
    In a brief July 25 email to an NDP staffer who was helping craft the announcement, Hassainia says she wants to make "some small changes" to the document. She gives no hint that the changes involve disavowing the party or taking issue with Mulcair's stand on Israel.
     
    Mulcair has been more unequivocal in his support for Israel than previous NDP leaders but he's walked a fine line on the conflict in Gaza.
     
    He has supported Israel's right to defend itself against Hamas missile attacks but has simultaneously pushed the federal government to help Palestinian children injured by Israeli missiles.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Premier Christy Clark says BC can be "counted as friend" of Israel

    Premier Christy Clark says BC can be
    In a letter to a Jewish Canadian advocacy group, BC Premier Christy Clark has aligned herself with Israel saying the province can be "counted as a friend" of Israel.  

    Premier Christy Clark says BC can be "counted as friend" of Israel

    UBC student dies after cliff fall at Stanley Park

    UBC student dies after cliff fall at Stanley Park
    An Abbotsford man, 22, was found dead following a tragic fall at Prospect Point in Stanley Park on Saturday. 

    UBC student dies after cliff fall at Stanley Park

    Arsonist setting fire at 3 downtown locations sought by Vancouver police

    Arsonist setting fire at 3 downtown locations sought by Vancouver police
    Vancouver police is searching for an individual who allegedly set fire in three downtown business locations Sunday afternoon. 

    Arsonist setting fire at 3 downtown locations sought by Vancouver police

    Vancouver's 36th annual Pride Week officially kicks off

    Vancouver's 36th annual Pride Week officially kicks off
    Vancouver's 36th annual Pride Week has officially kicked off with a declaration by Mayor Gregor Robertson. The festivities commenced at 11 a.m. in the council chambers at City Hall, where speakers discussed the lives of LGBTQ refugees in Vancouver and across the entire nation.

    Vancouver's 36th annual Pride Week officially kicks off

    Flight returns to Toronto airport after passenger makes direct threat to blow up plane

    Flight returns to Toronto airport after passenger makes direct threat to blow up plane
    Sunwing flight 772 was diverted back to Toronto's Pearson International Airport after a passenger made a "direct threat" to blow up the air plane.

    Flight returns to Toronto airport after passenger makes direct threat to blow up plane

    Canada announces sanctions against Russia, Ukraine

    Canada announces sanctions against Russia, Ukraine
    The Canadian Government has announced new economic sanctions and travel bans against Ukrainian and Russian individuals and entities.

    Canada announces sanctions against Russia, Ukraine