Monday, June 10, 2024
ADVT 
National

Ontario Court Upholds Ruling To Allow Sexual Activity Evidence In Boyle Case

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 12 Jun, 2019 07:00 PM

    OTTAWA — A lawyer for Joshua Boyle can introduce evidence of his client's estranged wife's past sexual history at the former Afghanistan hostage's trial, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice has ruled.


    Boyle, 35, has pleaded not guilty in the Ontario Court of Justice to offences against Caitlan Coleman, 33, including assault, sexual assault and unlawful confinement.


    The Superior Court judgment upholds a decision last month by trial judge Peter Doody that was the subject of a review requested by Coleman's lawyer Ian Carter.


    "The Court finds the Justice Doody was correct in finding that the proposed evidence has significant probative value which is not substantially outweighed by the danger of prejudice to the proper administration of justice," Justice Ronald Laliberte wrote in a judgment released Tuesday.


    The offences are alleged to have occurred in late 2017, after the couple returned to Canada following five years as captives of Taliban-linked extremists who seized them during a backpacking trip to Asia.


    In April, the defence made the application to introduce evidence concerning certain consensual sexual activity between Boyle and Coleman.


    Eric Granger, the defence lawyer, said the Superior Court review was unnecessary because sufficient safeguards are already built into the process followed by the trial judge.


    The issue is significant because the law limits the extent to which an accused person can bring up an alleged victim's sexual history during a trial.


    Such information is only supposed to be admissible if it's directly relevant to the case, and not to be used to suggest that a complainant is untrustworthy or was more likely to have consented to sexual activity because of his or her history.


    The Superior Court's decision could have implications for such trials in spelling out whether a complainant can challenge a ruling under the so-called rape-shield provisions.


    Coleman's lawyer argued that Doody failed to recognize a Supreme Court of Canada ruling that evidence of extrinsic sexual activity of the complainant is rarely relevant to support a denial that the sexual activity charged took place.


    Laliberte wrote that Doody was correct in finding the proposed evidence is relevant to an issue at trial.


    He noted that the defence position is that the alleged sexual violence did not happen and has argued that Coleman is consciously or unconsciously "inserting" into her evidence consensual activities that she and Boyle did, but added features to make those activities non-consensual.


    Doody had found the proposed evidence was relevant due to statements she made to police in 2017 where Colemen said she couldn't say with absolute certainty about what happened. She also said that memories can be invented and inserted.


    Laliberte said the court must recognize that a balance must be achieved in weighing Charter rights.


    "The point of all this is not to deny the importance of a complainant's right to privacy, dignity and equality in matters of sexual violence," he wrote.


    "An accused person who is presumed innocent and whose liberty is at stake should not be given lesser rights."


    Boyle's trial, which began in late March, was suspended last month over the dispute about the evidence.


    The trial is to resume July 2.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Trudeau worried China could target imports of other Canadian products

    Trudeau says he will see if it's appropriate to have a conversation directly with China's President Xi Jinping about a number of bilateral difficulties later this month at the G20 summit in Japan.

    Trudeau worried China could target imports of other Canadian products

    Ottawa pledges to spend $15 million to restore Ontario's tree-planting program

    Premier Doug Ford's Progressive Conservative government cancelled the 50 million trees program amid various other budget cuts.

    Ottawa pledges to spend $15 million to restore Ontario's tree-planting program

    Man who killed Calgary Stampeder must serve 18 years before applying for parole

    Nelson Lugela was found guilty earlier this year of second-degree murder in the death of Mylan Hicks.

    Man who killed Calgary Stampeder must serve 18 years before applying for parole

    Judge gives prison time to Calgary couple in toddler's infection death

    A jury found the Calgary couple guilty last fall of criminal negligence causing death and failure to provide the necessaries of life.

    Judge gives prison time to Calgary couple in toddler's infection death

    Canada's emergency alert system can't measure how many phones get the notices

    The most recent test of the warning system in early May was determined to be a success.

    Canada's emergency alert system can't measure how many phones get the notices

    Senate committee says oil tanker ban off B.C. targets Alberta, divides country

    The committee says it's driven by the calculation that the ruling Liberals have few seats to lose in Alberta and Saskatchewan.

    Senate committee says oil tanker ban off B.C. targets Alberta, divides country