Close X
Thursday, October 31, 2024
ADVT 
National

RCMP Entrapped B.C. Couple In Terrorism Plot: Judge Rules After Tossing Out Jury Verdict

Darpan News Desk, 29 Jul, 2016 10:14 AM
    VANCOUVER — Two people found guilty of terror charges will walk free after a British Columbia Supreme Court judge ruled they were entrapped by the RCMP in a police-manufactured crime.
     
    Justice Catherine Bruce said police instigated and skillfully engineered the very terrorist acts committed by John Nuttall and Amanda Korody, who believed they were planting pressure-cooker bombs that would blow up at the legislature on Canada Day in 2013.
     
    "The world has enough terrorists. We do not need the police to create more out of marginalized people," Bruce said in a landmark ruling Friday.
     
     
    "The defendants were the foot soldiers but the undercover officer was the leader of the group," she said.
     
    "Without the police it would have been impossible for the defendants to carry out the pressure-cooker plan."
     
    Bruce said RCMP officers overstepped their authority during a months-long, undercover sting and their actions were egregious.
     
    "The police decided they had to aggressively engineer and plan for Nuttall and Korody and make them think it was their own," she said.
     
     
    "To say they were unsophisticated is generous," she said, adding there was no imminent threat to the public from a pair who demonstrated they were not intelligent but naive.
     
    A jury found Nuttall and Korody guilty in June 2015 of three terrorism-related charges, but Bruce delayed registering the convictions at the request of defence lawyers, who wanted to argue the Mounties had entrapped their clients.
     
    An entrapment finding means Bruce will issue a stay of proceedings, which throws out the jury's guilty verdict.
     
    It won't appear on any criminal record and can't be used against the couple in the future. Had they been convicted, Nuttall and Korody would have a maximum sentence of life in prison.
     
     
    A stay of proceedings has the same end result but is different than an acquittal, which is a finding of not guilty.
     
    This is the first time in Canada the legal defence of entrapment has been successfully argued in a terrorism case. Three previous attempts failed.
     
     
    Timeline of B.C. terrorist bomb plot
     
    Feb. 23, 2013: The primary undercover officer involved in the RCMP sting, posing as an Arab businessman, first makes contact with John Nuttall. They reportedly lock eyes in a convenience store near Nuttall's residence. Two days later the officer approaches Nuttall with a request to help him look for his lost niece. Nuttall reveals to him that same day his desire to wage holy war on behalf of Islam.
     
    May 5, 2013: The undercover officer drives Nuttall and Korody to Whistler, B.C., so Nuttall can drop off a hard drive to one of the officer's supposed associates containing an outline of his alleged plot to hijack a Via Rail passenger train on Vancouver Island. During the drive it becomes apparent that Nuttall has not begun work on the document. The three spend several hours in a Whistler parking lot as Nuttall types up an outline. The undercover officer later scolds him for coming up with a poorly researched plan after it's revealed that the targeted rail line stopped operating years earlier.
     
    June 16 to 19, 2013: Officers set up Nuttall and Korody in what the pair believe is a protected hotel room in Kelowna, B.C., where they are told they can relax and work on their terrorist plot in peace. When the primary undercover officer learns Nuttall made no progress on the plan, he chastises him for not being invested enough in his terrorist plot, calling his actions a "sign of disrespect."
     
    June 29, 2013: Nuttall and Korody meet with an undercover officer posing as a high-ranking terrorist liaison. The couple is at first unsuccessful at persuading him to provide C4 plastic explosive for the pair to arm their pressure-cooker bombs but he eventually agrees to help. Nuttall and Korody disguise themselves with headscarves and film a jihadist video, which they intend to have released once their mission is complete. In it they outline their reasons for carrying out the bombing.
     
    July 1, 2013: Nuttall and Korody covertly stash sports bags containing homemade pressure-cooker bombs under bushes flanking the B.C. legislature shortly before 4 a.m. They head to a hotel after taking a ferry back to the B.C. mainland but soon become agitated when news of the explosions doesn't air on television. The two leave the hotel at 2 p.m., and are immediately arrested by police.
     
    Feb. 2, 2015: A jury trial begins on whether Nuttall and Korody are guilty of four counts of terrorism-related offences: conspiring to commit murder, conspiring to place explosives on behalf of a terrorist group, facilitating terrorist activity and possessing explosives on behalf of a terrorist group. The judge later dismisses the third charge of facilitating terrorist activity, citing legal reasons.
     
    June 2, 2015: After nearly three days of deliberations, a jury finds Nuttall and Korody guilty of plotting to bomb the B.C. legislature on Canada Day of 2013. B.C. Supreme Court Justice Catherine Bruce agrees to a request from the pair's lawyers not to enter the convictions until defence has the opportunity to argue that police entrapped the pair.
     
    July 13, 2015: Lawyers begin their arguments in B.C. Supreme Court into whether the RCMP entrapped Nuttall and Korody.
     
    July 29, 2016: B.C. Supreme Court Justice Catherine Bruce stayed the charges against the couple, saying the police undercover operation skillfully engineered the terrorist act committed by Nuttall and Korody.
     

    MORE National ARTICLES

    No Breaks From B.C.'s New Tax For Foreign Property Buyers With Deals: Minister

    No Breaks From B.C.'s New Tax For Foreign Property Buyers With Deals: Minister
    The tax takes effect next Tuesday and long-term contracts, such as pre-sale agreements for condos under construction, and pending property purchases involving foreign buyers will pay the new 15-per-cent tax.

    No Breaks From B.C.'s New Tax For Foreign Property Buyers With Deals: Minister

    Langley, B.C. Man Who Planned Arsons, Shootings At Family Homes To Be Sentenced

    Langley, B.C. Man Who Planned Arsons, Shootings At Family Homes To Be Sentenced
    Forty-three-year-old Vincent Cheung of Langley, B.C., pleaded guilty last week to 18 of 23 charges including arson and firearms offences stemming from attacks on 15 families in 2011 and 2012.

    Langley, B.C. Man Who Planned Arsons, Shootings At Family Homes To Be Sentenced

    Theft Of 8-Yr-Old Girl's iPad Results In The Arrest Of A Richmond Man

    Theft Of 8-Yr-Old Girl's iPad Results In The Arrest Of A Richmond Man
      The suspect, a 22 year old Richmond man who is previously known to police, opened his bag and relinquished the iPad to police. 

    Theft Of 8-Yr-Old Girl's iPad Results In The Arrest Of A Richmond Man

    B.C. Wants Federal Crackdown On Fentanyl Trafficking To Fight Health Emergency

    Premier Christy Clark wants the federal government to restrict access to devices, such as pill presses and tableting machines, and to pursue stronger penalties against people who import and traffic in fentanyl.

    B.C. Wants Federal Crackdown On Fentanyl Trafficking To Fight Health Emergency

    Jatinder 'Michael' Sandhu, Killed In Surrey Shooting Is Victim Of Mistaken Identity

    Jatinder 'Michael' Sandhu, Killed In Surrey Shooting Is Victim Of Mistaken Identity
    This is not a drug hit, not a gang-related hit, this is mistaken identity of an innocent victim

    Jatinder 'Michael' Sandhu, Killed In Surrey Shooting Is Victim Of Mistaken Identity

    Regulator Requires Banks To Conduct Stress Tests For Vancouver, Toronto Home Prices

    Regulator Requires Banks To Conduct Stress Tests For Vancouver, Toronto Home Prices
    Canada's banking regulator is requiring banks to conduct stress tests to determine how they would deal with a 50 per cent downturn in Vancouver real estate prices and a 40 per cent cut in Toronto home prices.

    Regulator Requires Banks To Conduct Stress Tests For Vancouver, Toronto Home Prices