Wednesday, December 17, 2025
ADVT 
National

Ruth Ellen Brosseau On Trudeau: 'Do I Have Justify How Hard I Was Hit In The Breast?'

The Canadian Press, 21 May, 2016 01:51 PM
    OTTAWA — Ruth Ellen Brosseau says she has faced personal attacks since she was elbowed in the House of Commons by Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, including that she should be "ashamed to be a woman" and that she is "not a feminist."
     
    In an exclusive interview Friday with The Canadian Press, the New Democrat MP said her office has received a number of phone calls from people across the country, many of them suggesting that she is "crying wolf."
     
    "My office has received countless phone calls ... saying it is my fault, I should be ashamed, I should resign, I should apologize, it is my fault," a visibly shaken Brosseau said during a conversation at her Ottawa office.
     
    "I get elbowed in the breast and it hurts. It was very painful."
     
    Brosseau, who used to to break up fights as a bartender prior to entering political life as the MP for a Quebec riding, said she never expected to have to deal with a situation like this once becoming a member of Parliament.
     
    "I am a tough woman, I know how to stand up and deal with situations," she said. "I was just shocked ... I was overwhelmed."
     
    Footage from the Commons television feed showed Trudeau trying to pull Conservative whip Gord Brown through a crowd of MPs, including Brosseau, who were milling about in hopes of delaying a vote related to the bill on doctor-assisted dying, C-14.
     
    In so doing, Trudeau collided with Brosseau, who could be seen reacting with visible discomfort as Trudeau pushed past her, forcing her against an adjacent desk.
     
     
    New Democrats reported hearing the prime minister mutter, "'Get the f--- out of the way.'" 
     
    Brosseau, who teared up several times during the interview, recalled how she felt herself beginning to cry in the immediate aftermath, and decided it would be best if she left the chamber immediately.
     
    "I wasn't going to go running after the prime minister," she said. "I was shaking ... it is completely inappropriate what happened."
     
    The prime minister had no right to behave the way he did, she said.
     
    "The prime minister intentionally walked over, swore at us, reached between a few members of Parliament to grab the (Conservative) whip ... how did he think he wasn't going to hit anybody else?"
     
    Brosseau said she has accepted Trudeau's multiple apologies in the House, including in the moments immediately afterward as well as the following day, but noted that the prime minister has not contacted her directly.
     
    On Thursday, Trudeau told the Commons he takes "full responsibility" for what happened.
     
    "I sincerely apologize to my colleagues, to the House as a whole and to you Mr. Speaker for failing to live up to a higher standard of behaviour," he said.
     
    "Members, rightfully, expect better behaviour from anyone in this House. I expect better behaviour of myself."
     
    Trudeau said he did not pay sufficient attention to his surroundings before making physical contact with Brosseau — something he regrets "profoundly."
     
     
    Brosseau said the scrutiny she has received since Wednesday's encounter has been worse than in 2011, when as a rookie candidate she was publicly ridiculed for travelling to Las Vegas during the election campaign.
     
    "I had a lot of media attention in 2011 and after that, I always wanted to just put my head down and work — and work hard," she said. 
     
    "This kind of attention, I didn't ask for it."
     
    She also said it remains painful to have to justify what she experienced, adding she feels like she is being attacked from all sides when she insists she did nothing wrong.
     
    "If I was a man and I was hit in the nuts, would we having the same conversation? I don't know," Brosseau said.
     
    "And then (people are asking), 'Was she hit hard enough in the breast?' Do I have justify how hard I was hit in the breast? It doesn't matter."
     
    She also said she has seen comments on social media suggesting she is minimizing sexual assaults and rapes. She said she has never made such a correlation.
     
    "Rape and sexual assault, domestic violence — those are serious, serious crimes and sadly it happens all too often to women and men across Canada."
     
    A Liberal-dominated Commons committee will now be tasked with reviewing the conduct of the prime minister, though Brosseau said she hasn't given much thought to what sanctions might be appropriate.
     
     
    "It is just going to be important, moving forward, what happens to make sure something like that does not repeat itself."

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Teenager 'Gang Raped, Strangled To Death' In Pakistan

    A 12-year-old boy was killed in a southern district of Sindh province in Pakistan after reportedly being gang-raped, strangled and thrown into a water drain by two suspects, the police said on Friday.

    Teenager 'Gang Raped, Strangled To Death' In Pakistan

    Justin Trudeau's Wife Shouldn't Get Extra Staff, Say Conservatives And NDP

    Justin Trudeau's Wife Shouldn't Get Extra Staff, Say Conservatives And NDP
    Sophie Gregoire was quoted this week in the Quebec City newspaper Le Soleil as saying she is overwhelmed by the crush of requests from groups that either invite her to speak or ask her to help promote their causes.

    Justin Trudeau's Wife Shouldn't Get Extra Staff, Say Conservatives And NDP

    Five People Treated In Hospital After Fire Erupts In Quebec Apartment Building

    Five People Treated In Hospital After Fire Erupts In Quebec Apartment Building
    Firefighters in the community just south of Montreal were called to the blaze at around 2 a.m.

    Five People Treated In Hospital After Fire Erupts In Quebec Apartment Building

    Bill Morneau Draws Laughs For Bringing Up His Quebec-Related Dating History

    Bill Morneau Draws Laughs For Bringing Up His Quebec-Related Dating History
    Bill Morneau told Quebec business leaders on Thursday he's always appreciated the province's open and friendly climate — but this time Canada's finance minister wasn't talking about investment.

    Bill Morneau Draws Laughs For Bringing Up His Quebec-Related Dating History

    Chicken Rentals Offer Test Runs For Would-be Backyard Farmers Wanting Eggs

    Chicken Rentals Offer Test Runs For Would-be Backyard Farmers Wanting Eggs
    Fraser, 34, says she always wanted to be a farm girl, and this month she helped other would-be farmers with similar dreams of eating yard-to-table fresh eggs by renting out several dozen chickens.

    Chicken Rentals Offer Test Runs For Would-be Backyard Farmers Wanting Eggs

    Nuclear Safety Commission Specialists Go To Fort McMurray In Precautionary Move

    Nuclear Safety Commission Specialists Go To Fort McMurray In Precautionary Move
    The commission says it got a request for assistance today from Alberta's provincial emergency operations centre.

    Nuclear Safety Commission Specialists Go To Fort McMurray In Precautionary Move