Friday, December 19, 2025
ADVT 
National

SC To Examine Legal Challenge To Abrogation Of Article 370, Refers Matter To 5-judge Constitution Bench

Darpan News Desk IANS, 28 Aug, 2019 08:23 PM

    The Supreme Court on Wednesday referred multiple petitions related to the abrogation of Article 370 to a Constitution bench while issuing a notice to the Centre and the Jammu and Kashmir administration on these petitions.

     

    A bench of Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi and Justices S.A. Bobde and S.A. Nazeer also allowed Communist Party of India-Marxist (CPI-M) General Secretary Sitaram Yechury to go to the state and meet his party colleague Mohammed Yousuf Tarigami.


    The court notice came despite the Centre requesting it not to issue it, saying Article 370 of the Constitution -- which gave special status to Jammu and Kashmir -- had international and cross-border implications.


    "We know what to do. We have passed the order, we are not going to change," the bench said.


    Representing the Centre, Attorney General K.K. Venugopal said it was a very sensitive matter and whatever happens in the country over it was raked up at the United Nations.


    The court asked the Attorney General if that meant the Supreme Court should not do its duty.


    The bench said it was aware of its duties and agreed to hear multiple petitions -- those challenging the Centre's decision to revoke Article 370 as well as those connected to the government-imposed clampdown and its consequences in the region.


    The bench headed by Chief Justice Gogoi said the petitions will be heard by a Constitution bench of five judges from the first week of October.


    The court was hearing petitions filed by National Conference leader Mohammad Akbar Lone, independent politician and former bureaucrat Shah Faesal, Kashmiri artist Inder Salim alias Inderji Tickoo and six retired military officers and bureaucrats who had challenged the decision to revoke Article 370.


    The Supreme Court also allowed Yechury to go to Jammu and Kashmir and meet his party colleague Tarigami but restrained him from getting involved in any other activity.


    The order came on Yachury's habeas corpus petition challenging the detention of Tarigami ahead of the abrogation of Article 370 on August 5. The plea also stated that Tarigami was not in good health and Yechury wanted to meet him.


    Solicitor General Tushar Mehta opposed Yechuri's plea saying his visit to the state could be used for political purposes.


    However, Yechury's counsel and senior advocate Raju Ramachandran said the CPI-M leader was ready to give an undertaking that he would only meet his colleague.


    "We make it clear that if the petitioner is found to be indulging in any other act, omission or commission save and except what has been indicated above i.e. to meet his friend and colleague party member and to enquire about his welfare and health condition, it will be construed to be a violation of this Court's order," the bench said.


    The bench directed a Senior Superintendent of Police to facilitate the travel and help the petitioner in locating the whereabouts of Tarigami.


    The court asked Yechury to file a report when he returns to Delhi.


    The court told Yechury not to use his visit for any other purpose and told Mehta that the government was free to stop the CPI-M leader and send him back if he did anything in violation of the court order.


    "If a citizen wants to go any part of the country, he must be given access," said the bench headed by Chief Justice Gogoi.


    The court rejected Mehta's offer of giving Yechury an escort during his visit. "There is no need to provide security," it said.


    Yechury had earlier tried to visit Kashmir with CPI General Secretary D. Raja on August 9. But the two leaders were detained at the Srinagar airport and sent back home.


    On August 24 again, he accompanied an opposition delegation to Srinagar. But the group was detained and prevented from getting outside the airport.


    In another habeas corpus plea filed by law graduate Mohammad Aleem Syed seeking information on the whereabouts of his family in Kashmir, the top court allowed Syed to travel to Anantnag and meet his parents.


    The court also ordered the Jammu and Kashmir administration to facilitate Syed's travel and provide him police protection. It directed him to file a report after meeting his parents.


    The top court also issued notice to the Centre on Kashmir Times Executive Editor Anuradha Bhasin's plea seeking relaxation on media movement in the valley and asked the government to file a response in a week.


    The Court issued notice on a plea filed by activist Tehseen Poonawalla, who has raised the issue of lockdown in the region as amounting to suspension of Article 19 (freedom of speech) and 21 (personal liberty) of the Constitution.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Vigil In Toronto Marks First Anniversary Of Greektown Shooting That Killed Two

    Community members held a moment of silence during the vigil, which began at sunset, as light rain fell on a busy stretch of Danforth Avenue where the shooting left two people dead and 13 others injured.

    Vigil In Toronto Marks First Anniversary Of Greektown Shooting That Killed Two

    Vancouver Police Say They Found Large Marijuana Cooking Operation

    Vancouver Police Say They Found Large Marijuana Cooking Operation
    Police say they dismantled the cannabis oil labs in an industrial warehouse area of Vancouver.

    Vancouver Police Say They Found Large Marijuana Cooking Operation

    Child Safe, Father And Three Others In Custody As Amber Alert Cancelled

    Child Safe, Father And Three Others In Custody As Amber Alert Cancelled
    Police in nearby Brantford, Ont., issued the alert early Thursday saying the girl and her father were last seen just after midnight leaving Brantford in a vehicle with two women.    

    Child Safe, Father And Three Others In Custody As Amber Alert Cancelled

    Father Of Suspect In 3 B.C. Deaths Expects Son Will Go Out In 'Blaze Of Glory'

    Alan Schmegelsky says his son, 18-year-old Bryer Schmegelsky, had a troubled upbringing. He struggled through his parents' acrimonious split in 2005 and his main influences became video games and YouTube.

    Father Of Suspect In 3 B.C. Deaths Expects Son Will Go Out In 'Blaze Of Glory'

    No Minorities, One Woman Sought Court Seat

    No Minorities, One Woman Sought Court Seat
    Former prime minister Kim Campbell says Canada could have a broader range of judges applying for spots on the Supreme Court if the government took a longer view rather than scrambling to fill seats opened by unexpected retirements.

    No Minorities, One Woman Sought Court Seat

    'Lock Your Doors': B.C. Murder Suspects Kam Mcleod And Bryer Schmegelsky Possibly Near Gillam, Manitoba

    Based on this information, police have sent a number of resources to the Gillam area. There will be a heavier police presence in the community.

    'Lock Your Doors': B.C. Murder Suspects Kam Mcleod And Bryer Schmegelsky Possibly Near Gillam, Manitoba