Sunday, December 28, 2025
ADVT 
National

Scotland Referendum disappoints some Scottish-Canadians

Keven Drews THE CANADIAN PRESS, 19 Sep, 2014 10:43 AM

    VANCOUVER - Nay may have won the day, but Caledonian-Canadians who supported Scottish independence in Thursday's historic referendum say their dream isn't dead, and at the very least change to the political system is coming.

    Fifty-five per cent of Scots who cast ballots in Thursday's referendum chose not to break their country's 307-year-old union with the United Kingdom.

    For Edinburgh resident Harry McGrath, who has dual British-Canadian citizenship, the vote doesn't mean an end to the sovereignty movement, especially with younger voters.

    "I don't get any sense here that the younger people in favour of independence are going to give it up. No, they'll still be there," said McGrath, the former co-ordinator of the Centre for Scottish Studies at Simon Fraser University in Burnaby, B.C.

    McGrath said he thinks the Yes forces could get another chance if politics in the United Kingdom don't change, the parliament at Westminster drifts to the right and Britain holds a referendum on its membership in the European Union.

    Political parties in Britain's parliament have promised to hand off more power to Scotland. In his comments after the results were known, British Prime Minister David Cameron promised to deliver on promises made to Scotland ahead of vote. But McGrath said some politicians are already balking at those plans.

    Still, McGrath said he's disappointed by the results because he voted Yes.

    "I still think it's a pretty amazing campaign by Yes to even get that close, but, nevertheless, it doesn't prevent you from feeling disappointed that we didn't go over the line."

    Leith Davis, a professor of English at Simon Fraser University and the current director of the Centre for Scottish Studies, said she was surprised the Yes and No sides were so far apart when the results were announced.

    Citizens and politicians will now have to reconsider the U.K.'s political arrangement, especially because the "fear of the possibility of independence" was raised in the last two weeks of the campaign.

    "I think there's going to have to be change," she said.

    Davis said she is disappointed by the results, but the world is now looking at Scotland differently.

    "I think to see a nation that can have this kind of conversation in a peaceful and democratic way where they're so strong, such strong difference of opinion, the rest of us should take notes and be envious," she said.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Imprisoned Egyptian-Canadian journalist Mohamed Fahmy files appeal

    Imprisoned Egyptian-Canadian journalist Mohamed Fahmy files appeal
    Lawyers for an Egyptian-Canadian journalist convicted in Cairo of terrorism charges have filed an appeal in an effort to secure a new trial, his family said Wednesday.

    Imprisoned Egyptian-Canadian journalist Mohamed Fahmy files appeal

    As CMA votes to oppose smoking plants, Tom Mulcair calls pot-puffing personal choice

    As CMA votes to oppose smoking plants, Tom Mulcair calls pot-puffing personal choice
    OTTAWA - Tom Mulcair defended the use of marijuana as a matter of personal choice Wednesday, recalling his own youth puffing on "oregano" even as the Canadian Medical Association officially warned against smoking pot.

    As CMA votes to oppose smoking plants, Tom Mulcair calls pot-puffing personal choice

    Manitoba children's advocate investigates whether social services failed slain teen

    Manitoba children's advocate investigates whether social services failed slain teen
    WINNIPEG - Investigations are underway to determine whether Manitoba's social services failed a 15-year-old aboriginal girl who ran away from foster care and was found dead in the Red River.

    Manitoba children's advocate investigates whether social services failed slain teen

    Shakeup at PCO as Wouters leaves office that oversees PMO's daily operations

    Shakeup at PCO as Wouters leaves office that oversees PMO's daily operations
    OTTAWA - Canada has a new top civil servant — and she's only the second woman to hold the position of clerk of the Privy Council.

    Shakeup at PCO as Wouters leaves office that oversees PMO's daily operations

    John Baird's Twitter activity prompts scrutiny of Canada's language commissioner

    John Baird's Twitter activity prompts scrutiny of Canada's language commissioner
    OTTAWA - When a minister tweets, is it ever really a personal account, or should he or she be required to abide by federal laws and responsibilities?

    John Baird's Twitter activity prompts scrutiny of Canada's language commissioner

    Spy agency improperly handled some information about Canadians: Watchdog

    Spy agency improperly handled some information about Canadians: Watchdog
    OTTAWA - Canada's electronic spy agency intercepted — and kept — several private communications of Canadians last year in violation of internal policies on personal information.

    Spy agency improperly handled some information about Canadians: Watchdog