Thursday, March 28, 2024
ADVT 
National

Sikh Kirpan Ban In Quebec Legislature Upheld By Top Provincial Court

The Canadian Press, 20 Feb, 2018 11:05 AM
  • Sikh Kirpan Ban In Quebec Legislature Upheld By Top Provincial Court
MONTREAL — Quebec's top court has upheld the right of the national assembly to prohibit people from entering with a kirpan.
 
 
Two members of the World Sikh Organization of Canada were challenging a unanimous motion adopted in the national assembly in February 2011.
 
 
The motion stated that security personnel had the right to refuse entry to anyone who did not want to remove the religious symbol.
 
 
Balpreet Singh and Harminder Kaur did not want to part with their kirpans as they headed into a legislature hearing to submit a brief in January 2011.
 
 
Originally, they argued the motion was unconstitutional but then changed their position to say it was legal but non-binding.
 
 
But Quebec Court of Appeal Justice Patrick Healy rejected their arguments in a decision Monday as he upheld a lower-court ruling that said the national assembly has the right to establish its own rules in accordance with parliamentary privilege.
 
 
Superior Court Justice Pierre Journet affirmed the authority of the legislature to "exclude kirpans from its precincts as an assertion of parliamentary privilege over the exclusion of strangers."
 
 
In his decision, Healy referred to a Supreme Court ruling that said a provincial legislature could invoke the privilege to exclude strangers to prevent journalists from filming in the precincts of the assembly.
 
 
"The Supreme Court confirmed that these general principles formed part of Canadian constitutional law and held specifically that the privilege to exclude strangers is entrenched in the Canadian Constitution," Healy wrote on behalf of a three-member panel.
 
 
"I make no comment whether the assembly's exercise of the privilege to exclude the kirpan is a wise decision.
 
 
"I say only that it is a legal exercise of this category of privilege. If the appellants wish to challenge it, the proper forum is the assembly itself."
 
 
Singh had no immediate comment.

MORE National ARTICLES

Justin Trudeau Announces Two-way Investment Deal With India Worth $1 Billion

Justin Trudeau Announces Two-way Investment Deal With India Worth $1 Billion
MUMBAI, India — Some of India's biggest companies say they will invest more than $250 million in Canada in the coming years in everything from pulp mills to pharmaceuticals and the IT sector.

Justin Trudeau Announces Two-way Investment Deal With India Worth $1 Billion

WATCH: Justin Trudeau Is For One United India, Looking Forward To Meet Punjab CM

WATCH: Justin Trudeau Is For One United India, Looking Forward To Meet Punjab CM
The Canadian prime minister’s schedule includes just half-a-day of official engagements in New Delhi.

WATCH: Justin Trudeau Is For One United India, Looking Forward To Meet Punjab CM

Vacationing Calgary Man Dies In Mexico Following Sudden Illness

Vacationing Calgary Man Dies In Mexico Following Sudden Illness
Troy Black was with his wife, Lindsay, in Puerto Vallarta when he began vomiting blood on Thursday. Doctors then found a tear in his esophagus, said his friend Jonathan Denis, a lawyer and Alberta's former justice minister.

Vacationing Calgary Man Dies In Mexico Following Sudden Illness

Liberals Looking At Creating Use-It-Or-Lose-It Leave For Fathers, Justin Trudeau Says

Liberals Looking At Creating Use-It-Or-Lose-It Leave For Fathers, Justin Trudeau Says
OTTAWA — Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says the federal government is looking at creating a use-it-or-lose-it funded leave for new dads.

Liberals Looking At Creating Use-It-Or-Lose-It Leave For Fathers, Justin Trudeau Says

Man Dead Following 'Targeted' Shooting In Coquitlam, B.C.: Police

Man Dead Following 'Targeted' Shooting In Coquitlam, B.C.: Police
RCMP were called to a residential neighbourhood on Friday night for several reports of shots fired and a vehicle speeding away from the scene.

Man Dead Following 'Targeted' Shooting In Coquitlam, B.C.: Police

B.C. Launches Formal Challenge Of Alberta Wine Boycott

B.C. Launches Formal Challenge Of Alberta Wine Boycott
B.C. says it has notified Alberta that it is formally requesting consultations under the Canadian free trade agreement's dispute settlement process.

B.C. Launches Formal Challenge Of Alberta Wine Boycott

PrevNext