Close X
Thursday, October 31, 2024
ADVT 
National

Some cities won’t hit child-care fee target: study

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 10 May, 2022 10:46 AM
  • Some cities won’t hit child-care fee target: study

OTTAWA - The federal government’s highly touted national child-care program aims to make care more affordable for parents, but a new study suggests just how much fees are reduced will depend on where they live.

The study by the Canadian Centre for Policy Alternatives says because provinces and territories are taking different approaches to try to meet the government’s initial fee reduction targets, some might miss them.

“It seems to me the challenge is not so much getting a plan up and running, it’s correctly implementing it,” said David Macdonald, study co-author and a senior economist at the centre.

The Liberals' 2021 budget promised $30 billion in new spending on a national child-care system over five years, and $9.2 billion annually afterward.

The government’s national plan is intended to cut average fees in half for regulated early learning and child-care spaces by the end of the year, and bring $10-a-day child care to every province and territory by 2026.

The four ways the provinces and territories plan to reach a 50-per-cent fee reduction include trimming set fees, giving a flat-rate rebate to parents without touching market fees, having each service provider halve their individual fees, and changing parent fee subsidies.

“Broadly speaking, most cities and most age groups will miss the federal targets. They won't miss them by much, but they will miss them,” Macdonald said.

Different types of child care exist for different child age groups, including infant, toddler and preschool-aged care, the latter being the most common.

For preschool-aged child care, seven of 26 cities included in the study’s analysis will meet or exceed federal targets in 2022, including Whitehorse, Regina, Oakville, Ont., and Ottawa.

Meanwhile, 15 cities will be close to their targets, missing them by about $20 to $100 a month, including Lethbridge, Alta., Toronto, Saint John, N.B., and Halifax, the study says.

The four cities that will miss their targets by more than $100 a month are Winnipeg, Calgary, Edmonton and Charlottetown, the centre found.

The reason Winnipeg is one of the cities with fees set to lag behind its target has to do with its approach, Macdonald said.

“The Manitoba government is not changing their set fees at all. They're modifying their subsidy system for lower-income households, such that the average reduction in fees will still be 50 per cent. But the benefit is really for lower-income households,” he said.

Macdonald said he hopes the provinces move to the set fee system, the most predictable and transparent way to get to the 50-per-cent reduction in child-care fees. Five provinces have adopted this method, including Quebec and most recently New Brunswick.

Many other provinces haven't touched the prior market fees, meaning whatever the child-care centre charged is still in place, and parents would be given rebates against the fee, he said.

“Those market fees are all over the place. They can be expensive, they can be cheap, they can be in the middle. It's much less predictable in terms of what parents might get,” Macdonald said, noting this route is harder to calculate and track for parents, and harder for provinces to manage.

The study says this approach will result in parents paying widely varying fees, though still less than what they were paying before.

Keeping the market system intact for child care also means it is unclear whether parents are actually going to get to $10 a day in three years time, Macdonald said.

Some might pay more than $10 a day as long as enough pay less than that to arrive at an average of $10, he said.

MORE National ARTICLES

B.C. will not change abortion rights: minister

B.C. will not change abortion rights: minister
Selina Robinson reacted strongly to questions about the status of abortion in B.C. and Canada following reports the U.S. Supreme Court may strike down the landmark Roe v. Wade abortion rights ruling.    

B.C. will not change abortion rights: minister

North Okanagan RCMP probe two suspicious wildfires

North Okanagan RCMP probe two suspicious wildfires
A statement from Vernon North Okanagan RCMP says officers are investigating "suspicious circumstances" surrounding two wildfires in the Westwold area on Monday.

North Okanagan RCMP probe two suspicious wildfires

Greater Vancouver home sales down in April

Greater Vancouver home sales down in April
The board says residential home sales in the region totalled 3,232 in April, down from 4,908 in April 2021 and 4,344 homes in March 2022. The April sales were 1.5 per cent above the 10-year sales average for the month.

Greater Vancouver home sales down in April

Teen arrested over string of attacks in Vancouver

Teen arrested over string of attacks in Vancouver
The 15-year-old boy from Vancouver was arrested Saturday night after three people were hurt in separate assaults that evening. Police say a 57-year-old man called 911 to say he was chased along the seawall near the Olympic Village by the teen, who repeatedly punched and kicked him.

Teen arrested over string of attacks in Vancouver

Vancouver Police find 51 year old woman dead inside a Mount Pleasant apartment

Vancouver Police find 51 year old woman dead inside a Mount Pleasant apartment
VPD responded to reports of a disturbance inside a building near Ontario Street and First Avenue around 2:30 a.m. on May 1. When officers arrived, they found the victim suffering from fatal stab wounds. She died on scene.    

Vancouver Police find 51 year old woman dead inside a Mount Pleasant apartment

Vancouver City Savings Credit Union experiencing technical problems

Vancouver City Savings Credit Union experiencing technical problems
Vancity Credit Union is asking that customers be patient while the organization resolves the issue of debit cards being declined. The Credit Union also reached out to its customers regarding intermittent system-wide problems in a Twitter post on Sunday.

Vancouver City Savings Credit Union experiencing technical problems