Sunday, July 6, 2025
ADVT 
National

Traffic Cop Should Know Better Than To Routinely Search Cars, Court Rules

Darpan News Desk, 06 Apr, 2016 12:53 PM
    TORONTO — A traffic officer who routinely searched vehicles he stopped was out of line and should have known better, Ontario's top court ruled Wednesday.
     
    In throwing out a drug conviction, the court found a car search by Const. Robert Sinclair violated the rights of the accused, Alexander Harflett.
     
    "I do not doubt that Const. Sinclair believes that he is doing the right thing," the Court of Appeal said.
     
    "(But) as an instructor of other police officers, he ought to be fully conversant with his legal authority — but the evidence shows either that he was not or that he was prepared to search regardless."
     
    Sinclair, with the Ontario Provincial Police highway enforcement team, was at a service centre on Highway 401 when he spotted a vehicle with Quebec plates. As a demonstration for a colleague, the officer ran a search on the places and found Harflett's driver's licence had been suspended for unpaid fines.
     
    The officer pulled him over down the highway, where Harflett, of Oshawa, Ont., produced a valid Quebec licence.
     
    Sinclair arrested him for using another licence while his Ontario one was suspended. He also called a tow truck to move the car from the highway to a nearby hotel to allow Harflett to pay his fines and get his licence back.
     
    Sinclair then took what he called an "inventory" of the vehicle — something he testified he always did — an approach that didn't sit well with the Appeal Court.
     
    "He resisted the notion that what he did was a 'search;' this was plainly a search," the Appeal Court said.
     
     
    "A check stop does not and cannot constitute a general search warrant for searching every vehicle, driver and passenger that is pulled over."
     
    During the search, Sinclair discovered marijuana in the trunk. He arrested Harflett for possessing the drug for trafficking purposes.
     
    At trial, Sinclair admitted he had been conducting a traffic investigation when he detained the accused and had no reason to suspect any criminality. However, he argued he needed to verify if the car had any valuables or dangerous items inside.
     
    In March 2014, Ontario court Judge Catherine Kehoe found his actions reasonable, decided any violation of the accused's rights was technical or minor, admitted the drug evidence, and convicted him.
     
    In throwing out the case, the Appeal Court found Sinclair had no authority for the search.
     
    "The inventory search cannot be justified on the basis of officer safety or any suspicion that the appellant was involved in criminal conduct," the Appeal Court said. "Sinclair had no public safety concerns, since he was going to release the car to the appellant."
     
    The court also noted two other cases where Sinclair had been found to have abused his search powers leading to the exclusion of evidence.
     
     
    "The impact of an unjustified search is magnified where there is a total absence of justification for it," the court said.
     
    Without the drugs as evidence, the prosecution had no case, so the Appeal Court entered an acquittal.

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Turbulent Battle As Golden, B.C., Fights To Save Local River Rafting Industry

    Turbulent Battle As Golden, B.C., Fights To Save Local River Rafting Industry
    Tourism officials in the southeastern B.C., town of Golden say letters of support are flooding in as they fight for access to the Kicking Horse River.

    Turbulent Battle As Golden, B.C., Fights To Save Local River Rafting Industry

    Vancouver And Toronto Markets Charge Ahead Despite Mortgage Rule Changes

    Vancouver And Toronto Markets Charge Ahead Despite Mortgage Rule Changes
    Moves by Ottawa to tighten mortgage lending rules did little to cool the country's two hottest real estate markets as home sales in Toronto and Vancouver continued to charge ahead last month.

    Vancouver And Toronto Markets Charge Ahead Despite Mortgage Rule Changes

    Canadian Bank Fined $1.1 Million For Failing To Report Suspicious Dealing

    Canadian Bank Fined $1.1 Million For Failing To Report Suspicious Dealing
    It is the first time the Ottawa-based Financial Transactions and Reports Analysis Centre of Canada, known as Fintrac, has penalized a bank.

    Canadian Bank Fined $1.1 Million For Failing To Report Suspicious Dealing

    BMO CEO Defends Canadian Banking Sector's Anti-money Laundering Practices

    BMO CEO Defends Canadian Banking Sector's Anti-money Laundering Practices
    Bill Downe says Canadian banks have "dramatically" beefed up their anti-money laundering controls over the last seven to 10 years at the request of various governments around the world.

    BMO CEO Defends Canadian Banking Sector's Anti-money Laundering Practices

    Ontario Kids With Autism Aged 5 And Older Cut Off Of Government-Paid Therapy

    Ontario Kids With Autism Aged 5 And Older Cut Off Of Government-Paid Therapy
    The Liberal government has announced a new Ontario Autism Program with $333 million in funding, but changes include limiting Intensive Behavioural Intervention to children between two and four.

    Ontario Kids With Autism Aged 5 And Older Cut Off Of Government-Paid Therapy

    Manitoba Election: Tory Ad Warning Of Tax Hike Goes Under The Microscope

    Manitoba Election: Tory Ad Warning Of Tax Hike Goes Under The Microscope
    In the lead-up to the April 19 Manitoba election, The Canadian Press is running a series of stories called Ad-Curracy, in which we look at the facts behind claims made in political advertisements.

    Manitoba Election: Tory Ad Warning Of Tax Hike Goes Under The Microscope