Sunday, July 5, 2026
ADVT 
National

U.S. 'cherry-picked' evidence against Meng: lawyer

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 28 Sep, 2020 09:23 PM
  • U.S. 'cherry-picked' evidence against Meng: lawyer

Huawei executive Meng Wanzhou is back in a Vancouver court today, where her lawyers are arguing the United States omitted or misstated facts to Canadian officials ahead of her arrest.

Meng is wanted on fraud charges in the United States, which she and Huawei have denied.

She is accused of misrepresenting Huawei's relationship with Skycom in a 2013 PowerPoint presentation to HSBC, allegedly putting the bank at risk of violating U.S. sanctions against Iran.

Canada's attorney general has said in documents that Huawei controlled Skycom's operations in Iran from 2007 until 2014, which contradicts Meng's statements.

Defence lawyer Scott Fenton told the judge hearing the extradition case in B.C. Supreme Court today that the United States cherry-picked information from the PowerPoint presentation that Meng made to HSBC in 2013 in its collection of evidence.

He said the summary of allegations provided to Canada is "manifestly unreliable" and "seriously misleading."

Fenton said the summary omitted slides in the presentation where Meng described Huawei as having a "normal and controllable" relationship with Skycom, and another where she describes Huawei and Skycom as business partners that both did business in Iran.

"It put HSBC on full notice that both Huawei and Skycom were doing business in Iran," Fenton said.

It means Meng and Huawei informed HSBC that if it chose to process U.S. dollars relating to commerce in Iran through it U.S. subsidiaries, it would be at risk of liability under American sanction laws, he said.

"After she's informed HSBC that its commerce with Skycom is in Iran, HSBC is on full notice in terms of measuring sanctions risk."

Fenton told Associate Chief Justice Heather Holmes that if she agreed there was an "air of reality" to the defence allegations that the United States failed in its duty to present fair and frank representations of what happened, she could order a stay in proceedings or an exclusion of the evidence.

"Where the court finds there are material misstatements and omissions going to the heart of the record of the case, then the court may intervene, find an abuse of process and fashion an appropriate remedy," Fenton said.

The attorney general is expected to deliver a response to the defence arguments on Tuesday.

MORE National ARTICLES

Bill Morneau leaves as suddenly as he arrived

Bill Morneau leaves as suddenly as he arrived
William Francis Morneau leaves federal politics as suddenly as he burst onto the Ottawa scene less than five years ago.

Bill Morneau leaves as suddenly as he arrived

Freeland sworn in as federal finance minister

Freeland sworn in as federal finance minister
Chrystia Freeland is now the federal finance minister, at a time when Canada is dealing with the biggest budget deficit since the Second World War — a job that will involve planning for an economic recovery as the COVID-19 pandemic continues.

Freeland sworn in as federal finance minister

N.B. Liberals announce ex-Tory as candidate

N.B. Liberals announce ex-Tory as candidate
Former Progressive Conservative deputy leader Robert Gauvin has flipped to the Liberals and took a swipe at his former colleagues Tuesday, calling them "ice cold" when it comes to helping the most vulnerable.

N.B. Liberals announce ex-Tory as candidate

Nisga'a leader Joe Gosnell dies at 85

Nisga'a leader Joe Gosnell dies at 85
A statement from the Nisga'a Lisims government of northwestern British Columbia says Gosnell died in his home in New Aiyansh after a long battle with cancer.

Nisga'a leader Joe Gosnell dies at 85

Many parents nervous about school: survey

Many parents nervous about school: survey
With only weeks until classes resume, a new survey suggests the majority of Canadian parents plan to send their kids back to school but most would want classes cancelled if there is a new COVID-19 outbreak in their community.

Many parents nervous about school: survey

Halifax constables given suspended sentences

Halifax constables given suspended sentences
A Nova Scotia Supreme Court judge on Monday handed two special constables with Halifax police suspended sentences with three years probation in the June 2016 suffocation death of an inmate at the city's detention centre.

Halifax constables given suspended sentences