Close X
Thursday, October 31, 2024
ADVT 
National

Vice Reporter Must Turn Over Materials To RCMP, Ontario Top Court Rules

Darpan News Desk, 22 Mar, 2017 11:36 AM
    TORONTO — A Vice Media reporter must give the RCMP the background materials he used for stories on an accused terrorist, Ontario's top court affirmed Wednesday.
     
    In a case that pitted freedom of the press against the ability of police and prosecutors to do their work, the Ontario Court of Appeal said it found no errors in an earlier ruling that went against the Canadian media outlet.
     
    Reporter Ben Makuch, backed by various media and civil rights groups, had fought the RCMP's production order, arguing police use of journalists to further criminal investigations would make sources reluctant to come forward.
     
    However, the Appeal Court said Superior Court Justice lan MacDonnell had been alive to a potential "chilling effect" in this case. 
     
    "(MacDonnell) was clearly alive to the concerns about the negative impact of requiring the media to produce material for the police," the Appeal Court said. "He implicitly addressed that concern as it existed on the facts of this case by identifying factors that tended to significantly reduce the potential 'chilling effect'."
     
    Those factors include an absence of a request by Makuch's source for confidentiality — in fact the source was "anxious to tell the world" about his beliefs and conduct, the Appeal Court said.
     
    Vice expressed disappointment with the Appeal Court decision but said it might try to continue its legal battle by seeking leave to take the case to the Supreme Court of Canada.
     
    "Simply put, this isn't over," the media outlet said in a statement.
     
    "Vice Media is prepared to do whatever it takes to support and defend our reporter, and our friend, Ben Makuch. His investigations into the complex world of cyber terrorism and digital security matter more now than ever. Ben's work and the vital principle of a free press must be protected."
     
     
    The materials in question relate to three stories Makuch wrote in 2014 on a Calgary man, Farah Shirdon, charged in absentia of various terrorism-related offences. The articles were largely based on conversations Makuch had with Shirdon via an online instant messaging app called Kik Messenger.
     
    One story cited Shirdon, 22, as saying from Iraq: "Canadians at home shall face the brunt of the retaliation. If you are in this crusader alliance against Islam and Muslims, you shall see your streets filled with blood."
     
    RCMP want access to Makuch's screen captures of those chats.
     
    In his ruling a year ago, MacDonnell said the screen shots were important evidence in relation to "very serious allegations" and that there was a strong public interest in the effective investigation and prosecution of such allegations.
     
    Makuch has previously said he had published all information relevant to the public.
     
    The Appeal Court rejected Vice arguments that the prosecution should have to prove the information the RCMP wants was essential to its case.
     
    "No one could accurately assess what the Crown does or does not need to prove its case at trial," the Appeal Court said.
     
    "To suggest that a judge can foreclose police access to relevant evidence otherwise producible in law — because the judge thinks the prosecution does not need the evidence to prove its case — is to seriously confuse the role of those who investigate and prosecute crime with the role of those who adjudicate the cases brought by the prosecution against individuals."
     
     
    The court did partly side with Vice on unsealing part of the RCMP's materials in the force's demand for Makuch to turn over his information.
     
    Lawyer Justin Safayeni, who represented a coalition of media and journalist organizations, also expressed disappointment in the decision.
     
    "The same concerns that motivated our clients to become involved in this case still exist today," Safayeni said. "Nothing in this decision reduces the chilling effect of production orders targeting journalists."

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Who's Happy, Who's Not: Norway Tops List, Americans Are Getting Sadder, Canada 7th

    Who's Happy, Who's Not: Norway Tops List, Americans Are Getting Sadder, Canada 7th
    A new report shows Norway is the happiest country on Earth, Americans are getting sadder, and it takes more than just money to be happy.

    Who's Happy, Who's Not: Norway Tops List, Americans Are Getting Sadder, Canada 7th

    High-Heels Debate Should Include Industries Other Than Restaurants: Experts

     Servers clad in short skirts and stilettos could soon be a thing of the past, as British Columbia and Ontario take steps to ditch sexualized dress codes. 

    High-Heels Debate Should Include Industries Other Than Restaurants: Experts

    Hudson's Bay Says Saks Customer Info Exposed Online By Accident On Weekend

    Hudson's Bay Says Saks Customer Info Exposed Online By Accident On Weekend
    TORONTO — Hudson's Bay Co. says the emails and phone numbers of some Saks Fifth Avenue customers were exposed online accidentally over the weekend.

    Hudson's Bay Says Saks Customer Info Exposed Online By Accident On Weekend

    Tegan And Sara Join YouTubers In Questioning LGBTQ Video Filtering

    Tegan And Sara Join YouTubers In Questioning LGBTQ Video Filtering
    TORONTO — A chorus of Canadian LGBTQ YouTubers, including pop duo Tegan and Sara, is calling for the video service to stop filtering out gay and trans-themed videos for some users.

    Tegan And Sara Join YouTubers In Questioning LGBTQ Video Filtering

    B.C. Tribunal Paves Way For Cyber Solutions To Small Claims Disputes

    B.C. Tribunal Paves Way For Cyber Solutions To Small Claims Disputes
    VICTORIA — B.C. residents will soon be able to sidestep a physical courtroom and fight many small claims disputes online.

    B.C. Tribunal Paves Way For Cyber Solutions To Small Claims Disputes

    Saskatchewan Premier Brad Wall Posts Video To Tell Residents About Tax 'Shift' In Budget

    Saskatchewan Premier Brad Wall Posts Video To Tell Residents About Tax 'Shift' In Budget
    REGINA — Saskatchewan Premier Brad Wall has posted a video message on Facebook in which he says there will be tax increases in the upcoming provincial budget.

    Saskatchewan Premier Brad Wall Posts Video To Tell Residents About Tax 'Shift' In Budget