Monday, January 24, 2022
ADVT 
National

Watchdog eyes CSIS efforts to disrupt threats

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 26 Nov, 2021 12:00 AM
  • Watchdog eyes CSIS efforts to disrupt threats

OTTAWA - Canada's intelligence service sometimes strayed from the law when trying to disrupt threats from hostile foreign states in the 2019 election campaign, the national spy watchdog has found.

In a newly released report, the National Security and Intelligence Review Agency sheds fresh light on the Canadian Security Intelligence Service's use of powers, ushered in six years ago, to actively counter threats.

Such measures could involve CSIS altering websites, blocking communications or financial transactions, and interfering with tools or devices.

The review agency looked at the topical issue of threat-reduction measures, approved in the context of the 2019 federal election, that were intended to ward off threats to Canada's democratic institutions.

In the run-up to the election, Canada's cyberspy agency, the Communications Security Establishment, warned there would be some kind of online foreign interference.

The CSE cautioned the meddling was unlikely to be on the scale of Russian interference against the 2016 U.S. presidential election.

But it said Canada could expect foreign adversaries to try to sway voters by focusing on polarizing social and political issues, promoting the popularity of one party over another, or trying to shape the public statements and policy choices of a candidate.

In its report, the review agency says most of the threat-reduction measures taken by CSIS during the period satisfied requirements spelled out in legislation governing the spy service.

It concluded, however, that in an unspecified number of cases the actions ran afoul of the CSIS Act because there was no clear link between a person implicated under the measure and the actual threat.

The review agency's classified report was presented to the government in February but a version with sensitive material deleted was made public only this week. Any details of specific disruption operations were excised from the document.

For all of the threat-reduction measures studied, the review agency found CSIS had met obligations, set out in a ministerial direction, to consult government partners and complete an assessment of the operational, political, foreign relation and legal risks of each measure.

The review agency's legal assessment of the measures looked at requirements in the CSIS Act that the spy service have "reasonable grounds to believe that a particular activity constitutes a threat to the security of Canada" and that the measure be "reasonable and proportional in the circumstances."

Most of the measures "satisfied the requirements of the CSIS Act," the report says.

But in a "limited number of cases" the spy service's inclusion of people "without a rational link" to the threat meant the measures "were not 'reasonable and proportional' as required under the CSIS Act."

One type of measure — no description was provided — entailed third parties acting on CSIS's behalf. Such a relationship would require CSIS to fully consider the Charter of Rights and Freedoms implications of its measures, and could require the spy service to obtain warrants before taking certain measures, the report says.

Overall, while CSIS use of threat reduction "remains limited," the intelligence service has been applying the powers to the full spectrum of national security threats, the report notes.

The review agency made recommendations including development of an accountability framework for compliance with legal advice on threat-reduction measures, such as documenting when and why such advice was not followed.

In a written response included with the report, CSIS says the Justice Department provides advice to ensure measures remain lawful and respect the rights of Canadians, adding the spy service "diligently applies these principles and guidance."

CSIS spokesman John Townsend said Friday the service welcomes the review body's contributions "in the spirit of continuous improvement."

"CSIS will always champion a sophisticated discussion on national security issues, especially those grounded in a Canadian context," he said.

"In today’s dynamic threat environment, government, civil society and the private sector must work together to protect our national interests."

MORE National ARTICLES

B.C. should prepare for 2 more storms: minister

B.C. should prepare for 2 more storms: minister

 Rob Fleming said people should prepare for two more storms expected to hit the province on Saturday and Tuesday following a major atmospheric river that devastated some communities where essential supplies are being delivered by air.

B.C. should prepare for 2 more storms: minister

Cannabis apparel OK to be sold at B.C. pot shops

Cannabis apparel OK to be sold at B.C. pot shops

B.C.'s private cannabis stores can now start stocking pot-themed clothing, books and other goods. The Ministry of Public Safety and Solicitor General announced today that private pot shops can immediately begin selling ancillary items that have a clear link to cannabis.

Cannabis apparel OK to be sold at B.C. pot shops

Man dies after suffering burns near Khalsa Diwan Temple: Abbotsford Police

Man dies after suffering burns near Khalsa Diwan Temple: Abbotsford Police

AbbyPD patrol officers responded to an assist Abbotsford Fire Rescue Service call within the 33000 block of South Fraser Way.  Upon arrival, a portable washroom was located, fully engulfed in flames.  A short distance away, a 28-year-old man was discovered suffering from severe burns. Sadly, the man has since passed away in hospital.

Man dies after suffering burns near Khalsa Diwan Temple: Abbotsford Police

Man convicted of 15 charges related to frauds: Surrey RCMP

Man convicted of 15 charges related to frauds: Surrey RCMP

Clayton Brooks Hayden plead guilty to 15 fraud related charges and was sentenced on November 16, 2021. He received a sentence of 15 months jail time, two years probation and was ordered to pay restitution to all 15 victims on the offences he plead guilty to.

Man convicted of 15 charges related to frauds: Surrey RCMP

Vancouver penthouse party host back in jail

Vancouver penthouse party host back in jail

Investigators discovered that Mohammed Movassaghi, 43, was running an illegal booze can and show lounge inside his 1,100-square-foot penthouse, packing it with hundreds of people, and violating Covid-19 health orders.

Vancouver penthouse party host back in jail

B.C. fruit and vegetable growers face uncertainty

B.C. fruit and vegetable growers face uncertainty

Sandhu's family came to Canada in the early 1960s and began farming about a decade later. Today, the 27-year-old and his parents grow a variety of berries and vegetables across about 120 hectares, while several other relatives have farms nearby in the Abbotsford area.

B.C. fruit and vegetable growers face uncertainty

PrevNext