Tuesday, December 30, 2025
ADVT 
India

V.K. Singh Stirs Row With 'Dog' Remark, Clarifies

Darpan News Desk IANS, 22 Oct, 2015 01:17 PM
    Union minister V.K. Singh on Thursday triggered a huge row when he spoke of a dog's stoning while commenting on the burning of two Dalit children. As opposition parties demanded his sacking, the former army chief clarified that he had been misunderstood.
     
    Asked about the gory killing by upper castes of the children in a Haryana village, the former army chief said: "If someone throws stones at a dog, the government is not responsible. It was a feud between two families, the matter in under inquiry.
     
    "Failure of the administration should not be put on the government's head," he added.
     
    The opposition immediately pounced on the Bharatiya Janata Party MP.
     
    The Congress sought his removal from the Narendra Modi ministry, adding he should be booked under law.
     
    "What V.K. Singh said was shocking, inhuman and unacceptable... I do not understand what is happening to Modi's ministers," spokesman Randeep Surjewala told the media.
     
    He said a case should be filed against the minister under the Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe (Prevention of Atrocities) Act, 1989.
     
    Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal also called for V.K. Singh's sacking and a police case against him.
     
    "V.K. Singh's statement is shameful and prosecutable," the Aam Aadmi Party leader tweeted.
     
    Bihar Chief Minister Nitish Kumar also slammed him: "Aghast at the senseless comment made by some BJP leaders including ... on the tragic Dalit killings in Haryana."
     
    Amid the volley of criticism, the minister clarified that his statement wasn't intended to draw an analogy. 
     
    "My men and I put our lives on the line for the nation irrespective of caste, creed and religion.
     
    "I standby to serve India with the same spirit, right now and always. Our nation, its success and its people motivate me daily," he said in a series of tweets.
     
    He, however, said that "localised issues" should not be blown up.
     
    V.K. Singh's comments follow the torching of a Dalit family's house in a village in Faridabad district bordering Delhi in Haryana that left two children dead and their mother in critical condition.
     
    The gory killings have triggered widespread condemnation and largescale street protests.
     
    The minister told CNN-IBN that if "anyone feels if I called Dalit dogs, they are out of their minds".
     
    Talking to reporters later, the minister sought to blame the media for mixing up his analogy of a dog's killing with the burning of two Dalit children.
     
    "If the journalist mixes the two (issues), the person should leave journalism and go to the mental asylum in Agra," he said.
     
    That comment too drew flak even as the BJP tried to defend him.
     
    BJP spokesperson Sambit Patra said: "The minister has given a clarification (that) he was misquoted.... Let us not blow it out of proportion.
     
    "A trend has started to politicise all issues on caste and communal lines. Let us not make everything a caste and communal issue," said Patra.

    MORE India ARTICLES

    Anonymous donor pledges $1.6M to 40 Grade 8 students

    Anonymous donor pledges $1.6M to 40 Grade 8 students
    An anonymous donor has pledged $1.6 million to 40 Grade 8 students in Leamington, Ont. 

    Anonymous donor pledges $1.6M to 40 Grade 8 students

    India launches Five Foreign Satellites, Modi wants one for SAARC

    India launches Five Foreign Satellites, Modi wants one for SAARC
    India Monday placed in orbit five foreign satellites, prompting a call from Prime Minister Narendra Modi to develop a SAARC satellite to be "dedicated to our neighbourhood as a gift from India".

    India launches Five Foreign Satellites, Modi wants one for SAARC

    Our Mars mission cost less than Hollywood film 'Gravity': Modi

    Our Mars mission cost less than Hollywood film 'Gravity': Modi
    The Indian space programmes are most cost effective and the cost incurred for the Mars mission was less than the money invested to make the Hollywood movie "Gravity", Prime Minister Narendra Modi said here Monday.

    Our Mars mission cost less than Hollywood film 'Gravity': Modi

    India to help 600 nationals return from Iraq this week

    India to help 600 nationals return from Iraq this week
    The government Monday said it will facilitate the return of over 600 Indians from non-conflict areas of Iraq this week, as efforts continued to secure the safe release of Indians in captivity in war-torn areas of the Gulf nation.

    India to help 600 nationals return from Iraq this week

    Harsh Vardhan clarifies on sex education, slams UPA's 'crudity'

    Harsh Vardhan clarifies on sex education, slams UPA's 'crudity'
    Seeking to end an "unseemly controversy" kicked up by his views on sex education, Union Health Minister Harsh Vardhan Friday denied that he proposes a ban on sex education in schools, saying he supports "pedagogy that is scientific and culturally acceptable".

    Harsh Vardhan clarifies on sex education, slams UPA's 'crudity'

    Five killed in Bihar train derailment, sabotage ruled out

    Five killed in Bihar train derailment, sabotage ruled out
    At least five people were killed when the Delhi-Dibrugarh Rajdhani Express derailed in Bihar early Wednesday, police said. Bihar Chief Minister Jitan Ram Manjhi ruled out sabotage while his Assam counterpart Tarun Gogoi asked a top police officer to visit the spot and oversee relief work.

    Five killed in Bihar train derailment, sabotage ruled out