Wednesday, July 16, 2025
ADVT 
National

Judge issues reasons for rejecting Meng evidence

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 21 Jul, 2021 03:12 PM
  • Judge issues reasons for rejecting Meng evidence

 A B.C. Supreme Court judge says she won't allow proposed new evidence in Meng Wanzhou's extradition case because it doesn't "expressly" support the Huawei executive's claim that the United States' case against her is "manifestly unreliable."

Associate Chief Justice Heather Holmes ruled July 9 against admitting the evidence but her reasons for the judgment were not released until Wednesday. 

Meng is wanted in the United States on allegations that she misled HSBC about Huawei's relationship with another company, putting the bank at risk of violating U.S. sanctions against Iran — charges that both she and Huawei deny. 

Meng's legal team argued that the documents undermine the allegations of fraud against Meng, proving the United States misled the court in its summary to Canada of the case against her.

The documents recently obtained by Meng's legal team from HSBC through a court agreement in Hong Kong include internal email chains and spreadsheets.

Holmes says in the ruling that while the documents would "no doubt be valuable to Meng in a trial," they don't expressly state Meng's conclusion, which can only be reached through inferences. 

"It is only inferences from the documents that support those facts or conclusions, and they are not the only reasonable inferences the documents support," Holmes writes in the ruling. 

The documents are also not capable of showing that the inferences made by the United States in its summary of allegations against Meng were unreasonable, she says. 

Holmes says that weighing competing inferences falls in the jurisdiction of a trial, not an extradition hearing. 

"Competing potential inferences may or may not play an important part in the trial, where witnesses will testify and be cross-examined, and the body of evidence will be far more complete," she writes. 

"In the context of an extradition hearing, the true or most appropriate inference cannot be determined."

The final two to three weeks of hearings in Meng's extradition case are scheduled to begin Aug. 3.

MORE National ARTICLES

RCMP search of 2 areas of interest in Lytton fire

RCMP search of 2 areas of interest in Lytton fire
A two-kilometre area in the nearby community of Boston Bar was also searched where physical and digital forensic evidence was collected and witnesses were interviewed, they said.

RCMP search of 2 areas of interest in Lytton fire

Power lines to Vancouver Island found damaged

Power lines to Vancouver Island found damaged
BC Hydro says it's working to repair a damaged underwater cable that delivers power to Vancouver Island. The utility says in a news release that its monitoring system detected a bulge and oil leak in one of its cables on July 8 that extends from the Sunshine Coast to Vancouver Island.

Power lines to Vancouver Island found damaged

123 COVID19 cases over 3 days

123 COVID19 cases over 3 days
Over a 3 day period, B.C. is reporting 123 new cases of COVID-19, for a total of 148,154 cases in the province. There are outbreaks. Laurel Place at Surrey Memorial Hospital, Eagle Ridge Hospital (Fraser Health) and Royal Inland Hospital (Interior Health).

123 COVID19 cases over 3 days

Feds launch tourism fund as business debt mounts

Feds launch tourism fund as business debt mounts
The federal government is offering easy financing for the country's beleaguered tourism operators, which the minister in charge says should help companies mired in debt.

Feds launch tourism fund as business debt mounts

Canada should reopen border to safe travel: Kenney

Canada should reopen border to safe travel: Kenney
The premier says he wants to see border rules relaxed to allow foreign nationals who can prove they are fully vaccinated to be allowed into the country without having to quarantine.

Canada should reopen border to safe travel: Kenney

3 hurt after crane falls in Kelowna, B.C.

3 hurt after crane falls in Kelowna, B.C.
A crane has collapsed at a construction site in downtown Kelowna, B.C., injuring at least three people. B.C. Emergency Health Services says in a news release that it received word around 11 a.m. that a crane had fallen onto an adjacent building.

3 hurt after crane falls in Kelowna, B.C.