Thursday, March 28, 2024
ADVT 
National

Supreme Court Sides With Toronto Man Over Detention In Race-Tinged Case

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 31 May, 2019 07:13 PM

    OTTAWA — The Supreme Court of Canada has set aside a man's gun- and drug-related convictions, saying police had no reasonable cause to walk into a backyard and begin questioning him.


    The 3-2 ruling comes today in the case of Tom Le, a 20-year-old Asian-Canadian man who was arrested by police at a west Toronto housing complex in May 2012.


    Le was chatting with four young black men in a backyard one night when police officers showed up.


    The officers were told by security guards who patrolled the housing co-operative that this was a "problem address" over concerns about drug trafficking in the rear yard.


    Two officers entered the yard without consent or a warrant, and began asking questions and requesting identification. A third officer patrolled the property's perimeter, then stepped over a low fence and told one man to keep his hands where he could see them.


    An officer questioned Le, demanded ID and asked about the contents of a satchel he was carrying.


    Le fled but he was soon tackled and apprehended a short distance away with the bag containing a loaded handgun, cocaine and a considerable amount of cash.


    At his trial, Le argued the police violated his constitutional rights to be free from arbitrary detention and unreasonable search and that the evidence should be excluded.


    The trial judge found that the police had legally detained Le, who unsuccessfully challenged the conviction in the Ontario Court of Appeal. He then took his case to the Supreme Court.


    In its decision, the high court says the actions of police that night seven years ago did amount to arbitrary detention, a serious violation of Le's charter rights.


    It says the reputation of a community — or the frequency of police contact with its residents — does not in any way license police to enter a private home more readily or intrusively than they would in a community with higher fences or lower rates of crime.


    "Requiring the police to comply with the charter in all neighbourhoods and to respect the rights of all people upholds the rule of law, promotes public confidence in the police and provides safer communities," the decision says.


    "The police will not be demoralized by this decision: they, better than anyone, understand that with extensive powers come great responsibilities."

     

    MORE National ARTICLES

    Rare White Young Killer Whale Swimming Off The British Columbia Coast

    VANCOUVER — A rare white killer whale has been spotted off the coast of British Columbia.

    Rare White Young Killer Whale Swimming Off The British Columbia Coast

    B.C. Premier John Horgan Rejects Liberal Calls To Dump Legislature Speaker Darryl Plecas

    VICTORIA — The British Columbia legislature became embroiled in political turmoil Thursday as Premier John Horgan rejected calls to replace the Speaker after the Opposition Liberals accused him of conducting a clandestine security probe.

    B.C. Premier John Horgan Rejects Liberal Calls To Dump Legislature Speaker Darryl Plecas

    We'll Work With Cities, Even When Provinces Won't Work With Ottawa: Trudeau

    In a speech today to members of the Canadian Federation of Municipalities, Trudeau specifically cited Doug Ford, accusing his Ontario Conservative government of blocking federal funding for local projects.

    We'll Work With Cities, Even When Provinces Won't Work With Ottawa: Trudeau

    With Trump's New Tariff Threats, New NAFTA Once Again Hangs In The Balance

    President Donald Trump says he'll put tariffs on all goods from Mexico starting next month, a surprise move that could blow up chances of ratifying the new North American free-trade agreement.

    With Trump's New Tariff Threats, New NAFTA Once Again Hangs In The Balance

    CBC Head Defends Coverage After Scheer Suggests Too Much Focus On U.S. Politics

    Catherine Tait appeared Thursday before a committee of MPs in Ottawa and was asked by Liberal MP Wayne Long to respond to Scheer's comments, which he said he found concerning.

    CBC Head Defends Coverage After Scheer Suggests Too Much Focus On U.S. Politics

    Woman Can't Have Embryo Implanted Without Ex-Husband's Consent, Court Rules

    Woman Can't Have Embryo Implanted Without Ex-Husband's Consent, Court Rules
    TORONTO — A divorced woman cannot have a purchased frozen embryo implanted over the objections of her ex-husband, Ontario's top court ruled on Friday in a ground-breaking case.

    Woman Can't Have Embryo Implanted Without Ex-Husband's Consent, Court Rules

    PrevNext