Monday, August 15, 2022
ADVT 
National

Trucker Jaskirat Singh Sidhu deportation case could go to court for Broncos crash

Darpan News Desk The Canadian Press, 22 Jun, 2022 09:53 AM
  • Trucker Jaskirat Singh Sidhu deportation case could go to court for Broncos crash

CALGARY - The lawyer for the former truck driver who caused the deadly Humboldt Broncos bus crash hopes he will get a chance to argue against his client's possible deportation before the Federal Court of Canada.

The Canada Border Services Agency recommended in March that Jaskirat Singh Sidhu be handed over to the Immigration and Refugee Board to decide if he should be deported back to India.

Sidhu's lawyer, Michael Greene, has already filed an argument with the Federal Court and expects written arguments from the Department of Justice by the end of the month. He said he will then have a chance to respond by July 22, when it will be placed in the hands of a Federal Court judge.

"A judge will decide if we've got enough of a case to grant leave. If the judge grants leave, then we argue the case in open court," Greene said in an interview.

"Based on what I've seen in the past, it's usually a few months before you hear what's going to happen next."

In March 2019, Sidhu was sentenced to eight years after pleading guilty to dangerous driving causing death and bodily harm in the April 6, 2018, collision that killed 16 people and injured 13.

Court was told that the rookie Calgary trucker, a newly married permanent resident, went through a stop sign at a rural Saskatchewan intersection and drove into the path of the Humboldt Broncos bus carrying players and staff to a junior hockey league playoff game.

Greene said he believes the system is flawed. He said one CBSA officer reviewed the evidence and made a recommendation to deport Sidhu, which was approved by a superior.

"I think the main thing is both officers were fixated on the casualties, which is not hard to do, and it was like basically saying the seriousness of the offence as judged by its consequences, outweighs all other factors," Greene said.

"This exercise is not to mete out punishment and that's what they're doing. They're meting out punishment … further punishment," Greene said.

"He already got the highest sentence ever for this kind of an offence. Now they're wanting to double down with permanent exile."

Greene said if there was a chance Sidhu would reoffend and put the public at risk, the decision would make sense. But he says that's not the case.

The Canada Border Services Agency declined to comment on Sidhu's case.

But a spokeswoman said in a statement that there are multiple steps built into the process to ensure procedural fairness and the agency would only act on a removal order once all legal avenues of recourse have been exhausted.

"All individuals who are subject to enforcement action and ordered to be removed from Canada have access to due process before the law, and all removal orders can be challenged through various levels of appeal."

Greene said he is cautiously optimistic he will get to argue the case in open court, but he said the way the system is set up, it could all end up back at square one.

"I'm kind of optimistic we'll get leave and we could well win in Federal Court. The problem is a victory in Federal Court sends it back to the CBSA and you just get a different officer," he said.

"I think the fundamental problem with the system is because the CBSA is an enforcement agency who doesn't dispense justice. It's all about enforcing the Immigration Act. It's about deporting people."

MORE National ARTICLES

Canadians confident in U.S., less in Biden: poll

Canadians confident in U.S., less in Biden: poll

In the Pew Research Center survey released Wednesday, only 61 per cent of Canadian respondents said they have confidence in President Joe Biden to do the right thing on the world stage — a steep decline from the 77 per cent who said the same thing in 2021.

Canadians confident in U.S., less in Biden: poll

Trudeau lands in Rwanda for Commonwealth summit

Trudeau lands in Rwanda for Commonwealth summit

Trudeau is in Kigali, the capital, where he will gather beginning Thursday with the heads of government from the other 53 countries in the Commonwealth for the first time since 2018.

Trudeau lands in Rwanda for Commonwealth summit

Hot spell for BC as of Friday, temps to spike into 30's

Hot spell for BC as of Friday, temps to spike into 30's

Special weather statements now cover the inner south coast, east to the Alberta boundary and north to Fort St. John, raising concerns that daytime heat and modest overnight cooling will rapidly melt still-heavy snowpacks, adding to flood risks.

Hot spell for BC as of Friday, temps to spike into 30's

PM heading to meetings in Rwanda, Germany, Spain

PM heading to meetings in Rwanda, Germany, Spain

He will first fly to Kigali, Rwanda, Tuesday night to meet with the heads of the Commonwealth nations for the first time since 2018. Canada is planning to promote support for Ukraine and condemnation of Russia at the meetings. The trip also takes Trudeau to Germany for the G7 Summit and then on to Madrid for a NATO Summit.

PM heading to meetings in Rwanda, Germany, Spain

Drunk driver who killed B.C. officer released anew

Drunk driver who killed B.C. officer released anew

Ken Fenton was convicted of crashing into Const. Sara Beckett's cruiser after running a red light in April 2016 near Victoria and was sentenced to five and a half years in prison.

 

 

Drunk driver who killed B.C. officer released anew

Gas tax holiday not high on Liberals' agenda

Gas tax holiday not high on Liberals' agenda

If the Biden administration follows through on that plan, it would make Canada the only remaining G7 country not to have recently cut gas excise taxes or offered a subsidy to help lower pump prices.

Gas tax holiday not high on Liberals' agenda

PrevNext